Tämä on FBI:n tutkinta-asiakirja Epstein Files -aineistosta (FBI VOL00009). Teksti on purettu koneellisesti alkuperäisestä PDF-tiedostosta. Hae lisää asiakirjoja →
FBI VOL00009
EFTA01129103
Sivu 41 / 465
4. Appropriate Spending: isamajivitta]. This means 2. being thrifty in spending your earnings. Anyone who has already expended so much effort in earning a day's wage should get full benefit from their own earnings without being extravagant and also without being so stingy they don't al- low themselves to use their money for any ma- terial comfort. C.4.2 Spiritual profit defined (A.iv.284) The wise man recognizes that he cannot live by bread alone and that for all the material wealth he might earn, it cannot buy him spiritual fulfilment. Thus a second important form of profit in life is spiritual profit— better known as profit in life for the hereaf- ter. This again consists of four virtues to be cultivated during one's lifetime [sampayikattha-payojarus]. 1. Faith or Confidence means faith that doing good deeds will lead to good outcomes (for the doer) and that doing evil will lead to bad retribution and giving rise to the commitment to perform the maximum of good deeds throughout one's life. Faith is the first step upon the road to striv- ing to do so many good deeds. Sometimes the clarity of peoples' minds is insufficient for their mind to be faithful continuously. They may be faithful when they wake up but later on in the morning the inspiration fades away. The Lord Buddha referred to such faith as 'turtle-head faith' because sometimes the faith shows itself like the head of a turtle, but just as often it will disappear out of sight inside its shell! This is not the nature of the faith of a wise man whose faith is steadfast and commitment continuous. 'Tur- tle-head faith' is not so hard to find — like the man who takes the Precept in the morning not to kill any living being but as soon as the tiniest of mosquitos tries to bite him he is slapping it as if his good intentions are all forgotten — but the mosquito disposed of he thinks, "Oh! Staking the Precepts today, all you mosquitos better get out of my way before I change my mind!" Such 'turtle-head faith' is no use to a wise man. With a mind that is crystal clear, a promise even to oneself, is a promise to be kept. The Precepts. You must keep the minimum of Five Precepts as the baseline of one's virtue be- cause the Precepts measure the degree to which you are a person as opposed to being a savage. Any time you want to find out to what extent you are human, you can use the Five Precepts as your benchmark. If all five of the Precepts have been perfectly kept, you can conclude that you are 100% human that day. If only four of your Precepts remain intact, you can conclude that you are only 80% human. If only three remain you are only 60% human, your fangs are begin- ning to show. If only two remain you are only 40% human, your fangs are longer and traces of a tail are visible. If only one remains you are only 20% human and the remainder of you is 80% savage. If none of your Precepts remain intact, nothing human remains about you. 'fry swap- ping yourself for a dog in anyone's house but no-one will accept the trade in. The dog is worth more than you are. You can fairly say that keep- ing the Five Precepts is the thing that closes the doors of hell. Because Five Precepts are the only thing that underpin our status in the human realm. Thus for the wise man, there is no doubt as to maintaining the Five Precepts and his hu- manness for the whole time, throughout his life. 3. Generosity: That we are still alive and well to- day on the long path since our birth is only be- cause we have relied upon the generosity of oth- ers all along the way. If on the day we were born, our mother had refused us her milk, our first day of our life would have been our last. If all throughout our childhood, our mother, father and relatives had refused us their care and at- tention, where would we be today? The fact that we have managed to learn to read and write and master knowledge of the world is only because our teachers have given their time and energy to educate us all through our schooldays Ividhayadana). Whenever we have made mis- takes, in our childhood and maybe only been punished for it and then forgiven (rather than being put to death for our errors) is because oth- ers have been prepared to forgive us our tres- Blessing Two: Associating with the Wise 41 EFTA01129143
Sivu 42 / 465
passes [abhayadana]. When you grow up and marry, again you can only get by as a result of the time and energy your spouse gives to sup- port you, sharing mutual earnings. Without such giving the marriage would certainly be on the rocks within the space of seven days. Ultimately, even the pavilion where you go to listen to ser- mons and the chairs you sit on to listen to it, all originate from the charity of others and that there is a monk with the time and energy to give you the sermon is another sort of giving [dhammadana]. Thus, in addition to faith and keeping the precepts, it is necessary to be gener- ous too if you are to number amongst the wise. 4. Wisdom [pan fia]: To be specific, anyone who is diligent in studying the teachings of the Lord Buddha will attain wisdom— the mark of a wise man. Anyone who lies around in bed all day has no chance of accruing wisdom. For the wise man, simply developing the four chambers of the mil- lionaires' heart is not enough. He must seek out wisdom too. When it comes to a holiday instead of lying around in front of the TV or going to the cinema, he is already on his way to the temple in the early morning to study what the Buddha taught. This is what we call seeking out wisdom. The fool is one whose understanding of profit in life conforms neither to material nor spiritual profit in life. Thus we can say that the wise man is one who understands and works towards profit both in this lifetime and the here after — i.e. both mate- rial and spiritual profit in life. C.5 Defined in terms of quality of mind The wise man is one whose mind is habitually pure. A person could be completely unqualified. He could even be completely illiterate — but if his mind is habitually pure, he is a wise man. The reason for this is that just the fact that the mind is pure has a snowball effect because it sets his standards of judgement and discretion and this alone will en- sure that wisdom is invested in everything he does — whether it may be thought, speech or action. b. RECOGNIZING A WISE ONE D.1 Tell-tale Behaviours (5) Many of the characteristics of a Wise One men- tioned above may not be immediately apparent to us because they are not external features. Thus we may have to look at the following five characteris- tics which will betray the wholesome inward quali- ties of someone who is wise: I. The wise like to shepherd others to live their lives in a proper way. Asked where one can go on a Sunday, he will reply, "to the temple of course — don't waste your time going to the cinema." Or passing him in the street, "it looks like rain, you ought to get the harvest in before it spoils." If you were to meet a fool in the same circum- stances, give you altogether different ad- vice — "it oolcs like rain, if you're feeling aches & pains be better off down at the bar with a stiff w es y down your throat!" Both the fool and the wise man are persuaders but their per- suasion leads to different results indeed. 2. The wise take fidl responsibility for the things that are their own business. Apart from being responsible, they will influence those around them to be responsible in the same way. What the wise won't do is interfere with other peo- ples' business. They know where to draw the line in order to avoid nosing into others' affairs. The fool by contrast is often more interested in inter- fering in other peoples' business than he is about taking responsibility for what he's meant to be doing. 3. The wise favour the honest and the decent. Its no use trying to persuade him to be dishonest or unscrupulous, because he is above those sort of things. The fool by contrast is proud of the fact that he can get away with anything. Nothing is too low for him. 4. The wise man is not easily angered. He is grate- ful for criticism from others. The fool, by con- trast, even if criticized in the politest of ways will lose his temper. Even if someone offers him criti- cism with the best of possible intentions, he'll turn round with a scowl and answer back, "you've been constantly picking on my faults". 42 A Manual of Peace: 38 Steps towards Enlightened Living EFTA01129144
Sivu 43 / 465
FI
If you smile at him, he'll interpret your smile as teasing and turn his back on you. Even just speaking to a fool can make him lose his temper. Sometimes you don't even need to say anything. Just seeing you look at him can upset him — "What are you looking at me like that for?" The fool is constantly on the lookout for a fight. The wise man by contrast is hard to stir to anger. Thus if you recognize yourself as hot-tempered, you ought to associate with the wise and this will gradually cool down your fiery temper. How- ever, you shouldn't confuse the cool-tempered wise man with the inert and irresponsive char- acter of the sort of guy who sleeps all day and seems to do everything in slow-motion. These dopey sorts are irresponsive to nearly everything around them, but don't think they're free of all defilements. They are another breed of person altogether from the wise men we aim to associ- ate with. 5. The wise favour self discipline and orderliness. When we live together in society with a huge number of other people, if we don't comply with the laws laid down in society, we end up as mis- anthropes. The regulations say that when you are at the temple, at the appropriate time you must come to sit in the main pavilion and sit in neat lines, without encroaching on the people sitting next to you, that way there is enough space for everyone and everyone has an equal area to sit in. The fool, however, doesn't respect the rules. He doesn't like obeying anyone or any- thing. He'll be the only one to sit out of line, stick- ing out like a sore thumb. He's like a spanner in the works. For temples in general, people go to the temple with the best of intention to accrue as much merit as possible but when it comes to mealtimes, they end up fighting to get to the front of the queue like vultures. In the morning they are like angels walking on the Earth, but when lunchtime comes, they are like hungry ghosts! In conclusion, the good thing about associating with the wise is that it will develop our discretion to be that of the wise with whom we associate — or to come to the real point — it will allow our mind to become bright and clear like that of the wise man. 112 Qualities of a IVise One's Friendship Alternatively, the Wise One can also be noticed by his characteristics of being a true friend who exhib- its all three sorts of responsibility: • responsibility for his own personal dignity • responsibility for the human dignity of oth- ers • responsibility for a fair economic system In our association with such Wise Ones, we will be able to recognize their level of responsibility from the quality of their friendship. If we are a good friend to them, then we should see the following characteristics in the friendship which is returned. However, even amongst True Friends, the respon- sibility can be manifested in different ways. The Buddha subdivided True Friends into four groups. He identified each group by four examples of be- haviours — giving a total of sixteen characteristics to look for in a good friend. 1. The Helpful Friend lupakarakal 2. The Constant Friend isamanasukhadukkha] 3. The Friend of Wise Counsel Iatthokkhayil 4. The Sympathetic Friend Ianukampaka] 1. a helpful friend is one who: 1. protects you even when you are off your guard; 2. helps protect your property even when you neglect it; 3. is your refuge in times of danger; 4. always provides you with twice as much as you asked for; 2. a constant friend is constant in bad times and good: 1. they confide in you; 2. they don't go spreading your secrets around; 3. they don't abandon you when you fall on hard times; 4. they would even die in your place; 3. they give you good counsel: 1. they warn you against unwholesome behaviour 2. encourage you towards wholesome behaviour; 3. save up new things to tell you; Blessing Two: Associating with the IVise 43 EFTA01129145
Sivu 44 / 465
4. point you in the direction of heaven. 4. they empathize with you: 1. they don't laugh at your misfortunes; 2. they congratulate you on your good fortune, 3. they speak out against anyone who maligns you, 4. they stand up for those who speak well of you As you can see, all sixteen characteristics of the True Friend are characteristics that lead to the creation of positivity. E. ASSOCIATION £1 How to associate with the wise (7) The Lord Buddha taught seven features of behav- iour which counts as association with the wise. If your association misses out on any of these seven factors, it cannot be counted as fruitful association. The seven features are as follows: 1. Frequently meeting up with them. If you know that someone has the characteristics of a wise man, you ought to seek him out and visit him regularly. If you hear that such and such a tem- ple has wise people going to it, then that should be the temple you are visiting regularly. This is the first step to true association. Without it no association can come about. 2. Make yourself known to them. What this means is that when you have gone out of your way to seek out a wise man, you should make yourself known to them, not sit just out of their line of vision round the corner. Whenever they go to the boxing or the fashion show they are right at the ringside or up against the catwalk, but when they go to the temple and see one of the monks coming, they will disappear to the back row of the pavilion. In such a case, even though they have come as far as the temple where the wise are to be found, they cannot be said to have as- sociated with the wise. 3. Sincerety towards them. If there is any affection in your association, you must be sincere to one another—with nothing behind your back. There is no secret which your other half can't ask about and get a straight answer. Loyalty means that 4. 5. 6. 7. there is no hidden agenda concerning your as- sociation. But even this is not enough. Loyalty towards them. Where in sincerety, your association is bound through affection, in loy- alty the association is bound through respect. Thus to make for the best of possible associations you should do nothing to diminish either the love or respect that bonds the relationship. Also you should do nothing to interrupt the train of thought of the wise man with whom you have chosen to associate whether it be through care- less speech or otherwise. This is what we call loyalty. Help them in times of need. Whenever we notice that our associate (the wise one) is busy with something we could help with, we should offer our help without reluctance. However, if we know that our associate has something that we could help with and we keep our silence instead of offering our assistance, we can hardly call our association a friendship. Just imagine if a group of so-called friends all come together at meal time but cannot be found when it comes to time for work. Such a group could hardly be called friends. When free j . ' g up to talk and eat together. When the wise have free time they come together to discuss the Dhamma and to clear up their doubts (not to gossip about the neighbours). Reflection on Dhamma and Getting Down to Earnest Practice. This is one of the most impor- tant headings. Even if you have diligently fol- lowed the previous six steps but omit this sev- enth step, you cannot call it true association. Also, if you do none of the first six but do the seventh one, it is as good as true association, because Dhamma always has the same flavour — it al- ways gives rise to self discipline [sik]: it always gives rise to concentration [samadhi]: and it al- ways gives rise to wisdom Ipafifio]. Thus even if you have never met your wise associate be- fore, even on your first meeting you will feel as if you have been friends for a thousand years, or for many lifetimes — because both of you have Dhamma in your hearts — it is Dhamma that binds your association. 44 A Manual of Peace: 38 Steps towards Enlightened Living EFTA01129146
Sivu 45 / 465
The behaviour that we refer to as association means that that whatever happens you will do things in togetherness. If there is work you will work to- gether. Accept each others' help, accept the same identity, accept the same place of abode, accept work in the same place. If you possess anything, you will be willing to lend it to them or give it to them, giving them possessions or respect. In con- clusion the operant parts of the process of associa- tion with the wise are sharing, accepting and giv- ing. If you expand upon these three then you ar- rive at the seven steps described at the beginning of this section. £2 Principles of Association Like all the groups of people closest to us in the world, the best way we can get the virtues of the wise to brush off on us is associate with them as 'good friends'. The Buddhist teaching most relevant to the cultivation of a fruitful friendship is the 'northern quarter' of the Singalovida Sutta which gives us the following practical advice about how good friends should treat each other: The Buddha laid down five examples of duties we ought to practice in order to express our respon- sibility towards our friends: 1. generosity: anyone possessed of Right View [sanunn clitthi] is bound to moved to compas- sion when seeing others experiencing hardship or suffering—and generosity is the way in which he can ameliorate the lot of friends caught in such a situation, while at the same time strengthen- ing his bond of friendship to that person; 2. kind words: if a person is able to relinquish the Four Defilements of Action, and has the altru- ism of a Good Friend [k,alyariamitta] he will be of the habit of speaking only words that are po- lite and true; 3. helping and acting for their welfare: endowed with the characteristics of a True Friend, one will have the altruism to want to do things for the benefit of one's friends; 4. being consistent: however well one has treated one's friends in the past, one will not suddenly change to treat them better or worse because of force of circumstances. Just because one gets a promotion in rank which is better than that of one's old friend, one will not subsequently look down on him; 5. never telling them lies: as good friend what one says will never deviate from the truth. It is only possible to fulfil the demands of these five duties if one has already had the qualifies of a true friend instilled by effective upbringing at the hands of one's parents, teachers and employers. In turn those wise friends should practice the fol- lowing five duties towards us in order to express their sense of responsibility towards us: 1. protect us when we are off our guard: learning that we are in the midst of problems as a result of our own recklessness, if it happens that such recklessness is not in our nature, if a friend is true, they will intervene and help — if they leave us to our recklessness you can know that they are an enemy in a friend's guise; 2. help protect our property even when we neglect it: such is the behaviour of a true friend; 3. be our refuge in times of danger: willingness to let us rely on them is the sign of a true friend; 4. not abandoning us in times of trouble: this is the sign of a Good Friend Elealyagamittal; 5. show due respect to other members of our fam- ily: friends who not only show us respect, but also respect those to whom we have debts of gratitude, our children and grandchildren as if they were part of their own family — are indeed true friends. All five duties of a friend are identifying features of a truly Good Friend — if we ever have the luck to come across such a genuine friend, we must take care to associate closely with them, treating them with respect, in keeping with the Buddha's advice: "associate with them respectfully, like a mother to her sons" It is pertinent to observe that such a genuine friend could only arise in the world as the result of an amenable environment (see forthcoming Blessing Four), especially those in whose company they grew up, in order for the good habits of those people to Blessing Two: Associating with the IVise 45 EFTA01129147
Sivu 46 / 465
have brushed off on him and been preserved in his own personality. It is such people that society and nation alike are crying out for — because such a person has tremendous power of virtue stored up inside them — sufficient power to channel the tide of society and economics around him down the same virtuous path. .E.3 What are the consequences when there are no Wise Ones to be found? If there are no genuinely wise ones to be found in society or if those posing as 'wise' fail to cherish others according to the advice of the Buddha, many sorts of harm arise on individual, interpersonal and social levels. Many of the potential problems can be extrapolated to the relationship between gov- ernment and the citizens it is supposed to be a ref- uge too. If the government fails to be a Wise Friend toils citizens, it the false friendship brings serious problems on a national level. In conclusion, the harm that arises when there is lack of association with the wise manifests itself on three levels: 1. Losing a sense of responsibility for their own human dignity: If friends lack self-discipline and don't fulfil their duties towards one another as prescribed by the Lord Buddha, the first level of disaster which will happen to them is that they will lose their sense of responsibility for their own human dignity — this loss giving rise (at the minimum) to the following three undesirable symptoms: 1. Breaking the Five Precepts: Because there is an atmosphere of mutual suspicion, former friends will deceive and lie to each other. The pledges of allegiance they formerly kept to one another will be nullified in the way often seen in political circles; 2. Chronic False View: Lacking discretion as to right and wrong, virtue and misdeed, appro- priate and inappropriate and the Law of Karma, there is nothing they will not do as a means to procure power, money and personal profit; 3. Mistreats Friends: They might resort to back stabbing of former friends in order to procure personal ends; 2. Losing a sense of responsibility for the human dignity of others: If friends lack self-discipline and don't fulfil the duties towards one another prescribed by the Lord Buddha, the second level of disaster which will happen to them is that they will lose their sense of responsibility for the hu- man dignity of others — this loss giving rise (at the minimum) to the following three undesirable symptoms: 1. Harbours bias: They will lose their sense of fair- ness and will be continually biased in favour of their own cronies — not with altruistic thoughts for even their own people, but in order to pave the way to personal profit; 2. Disloyalty to homeland: Out of selfishness and False View, they will become narrow-minded and unrefined in their thinking. All they will think about is how to maximize the profits they can procure for themselves and their cro- nies — to the point they will no longer have any sense of loyalty to their own country, re- ligion or nationality — they wouldn't feel any scruples about making a profit, even if they have to destroy the national heritage to do so; 3. Misuse of rank or position: When they lack any accurate sense of justice, they will attempt to make illegal dealings look legal or outlaw le- gal things, if it suits them to do so. 3. Losing a sense of responsibility for economic fairness in society at large: If friends lack self- discipline and don't fulfil the duties towards one another prescribed by the Lord Buddha, the third level of disaster which will happen to them is that they will lose their sense of responsibility for economic fairness in society at large — this loss giving rise (at the minimum) to the follow- ing three undesirable symptoms: 1. Corruption: When false view and selfishness get the better of their thinking, they will wor- ship money alone—because they understand that the more money they have, the more power they can gain. Money will be the means that they can secure the any position of au- thority they hold (through bribery). 46 A Manual of Peace: 38 Steps towards Enlightened Living EFTA01129148
Sivu 47 / 465
2. Implicated in dealings with the Six Roads to Ruin: When money becomes important above all else, they will have no scruples about taking shortcuts to find it. Of course the most profit- able forms of trading are dealing in drugs, for- geries, arms smuggling or casinos — the fad that they are illegal or exploit the poorest sec- tors of society — considerations which mean nothing to those so far alienated from thoughts of fairness in economics; 3. Betrays homeland: if such people find them- selves in positions of legislation, because of selfishness and False View, if they can make a 'quick buck' from foreign investors, they will not think twice about waiving laws which for- merly protected their country from foreign exploitation. The problems of lack of association with the Wise can be summarized down to two main points: 1. Obvious social problems: In countries such as Thailand, social problems which are out of hand are high-level corruption, partiality of the legal system, degeneration into vice and widespread prostitution; 2. Covert social problems: The covert social prob- lems exist in the form of False Friends in posi- tions of influence — whether it be positions in politics, the civil service, government utilities— who have less than scrupulous behaviour. Un- fortunately what the people see of such public figures — an image of respectability and chiv- alry — often belies illicit dealings behind the scenes. Such false friendship has its origins in undisciplined parental upbringing, undisci- plined schooling and eventually, having become a fool, seeking the company of other fools is the final nail in the coffin of true friendship. Possible solutions to these problems are: 1. In the short term are to avoid voting those with the character traits of 'false friends' into positions of authority; 2. In the long term are to use the nets of 'sixteen characteristics of true friends' and 'sixteen char- acteristics of false friends' to identify and replac- ing the weaknesses in yourself with virtues start- ing with yourself— associating with the wise so that their good virtues can brush off on you too. VARIEI WISE; ONES El Inner teacher, outer teacher Broadly speaking, there are two categories of the wise—the outer wise ones and the inner wise ones. The outer wise ones can be subdivided into the wise who are truly wise and those who are not truly wise. The truly wise are start with the Lord Buddha, the arahants and those who have attained the various levels of Buddhist sainthood. The wise who are not truly wise are those who are as wise as or wiser than us. Examples of these are monks who truly train themselves in meditation. Even though such monks may not be arahants, they come up to the standard of a wise man. You should seek him out for association and familiarize yourself with his vir- tues. You can only gain from such association. As for your own parents, given that we are their chil- dren, we ought to do our best to associate with them. Sometimes we encounter difficulties how- ever. Sometimes our parents have the character of fools. If this should be the case then we have the duty to live in the same household, but with the utmost care not to let those foolish habits rub off on ourselves. If your parents drink alcohol, don't go prohibiting them from such behaviour. It is not your place to do so. However, at the same time you shouldn't go joining them in their drinking. If your mother loves playing poker, it's no good telling her to give up. Let her carry on with her gambling — but don't go joining in with her. Even though we know these are the habits of a fool, they are our own mother and father. We can't just ditch them. We must carry on living in the same household while taking care not to be infected by their foolish habits. The wise also extend to our friends and relatives who are a good example to us by their behaviour. Even if they might not be right all the time, or they may not be as wise as an arahant, to associate with them is still to our benefit. In the case of associating with the wise who are not yet perfect, the Buddha taught that we should Blessing Two: Associating with the Wise 47 EFTA01129149
Sivu 48 / 465
concentrate on observing only their good points and mimic only these good behaviours. If that person has his faults, don't waste your time criticising them for these, because for as long as one hasn't come to an end of all defilements, faults and weaknesses will always remain. Don't go looking for peoples' faults. Look for their strengths and make the effort to instil these strengths in ourself. In the end we will be like an ocean full of all types of virtue. Don't go letting someone's minor fault blind you to all their virtues. If you are only interested in peoples' faults, by the time you have picked out everyone's weaknesses, there will be only one good person left in the world — yourself. Thus the wise in the outside world are of two types: the permanently wise who have rid them- selves of all defilements and the sporadically wise who still have defilements remaining. Both types of wise ones are beneficial to associate with. You may have noticed that sometimes when we think of doing something evil there will be a little voice inside that warns us not to do it. Have you wondered where that little voice inside comes from? Usually we cannot see whose voice it is, but if we meditate until our mind is much dearer, we will be able to see the wise one inside who is the owner of the voice. Information, whether it be in the form of knowledge as a voice or the content of a dream or sixth sense, is transferred down the line from deep inside ourselves, like a baton between the runners of a relay race. G. THE PRACTICALITY OF CIII,ERA I 'NG ASSOCIATION WITH THE WISE It is for this reason that we must do two things— try to find the wise in the outside world and find the best ways to associate with them. If we know that anyone is a good example then we should make sure we get to know that person. That way the good character that makes that person a wise one will begin to brush of on us as well. Secondly, once we have seen the nature of those who are a good ex- ample to follow, we should start to cultivate an in- ner self which has the same good qualifies so that the self which is wise will manifest itself inside ourselves. If we already have an inner self that is wise, even if we don't meet any more wise people ever again, it will not matter to us, because we have our inner source of wisdom from which we can draw the knowledge of our inner teacher. H. ILEUM RAI in, MAMMALS H.1 Metaphor: Leaves wrapping a perfumed fish A parable used by the Lord Buddha is that of the leaves wrapping a perfumed fish taking on the same perfume as the fish itself. H.2 Red-Bearded Executioner saved by Association with the Wise (Dlutii.203) Tambadithika who was a former thief had served the king as the public executioner for fifty-five years; and had just retired from that post. One day, he went to the river for a bath, intending to take some specially prepared food on his return home. As he was about to take the food, Venerable Sariputta, who had just arisen from sustained ab- sorption in concentration [}hang sanzapatti], stood at his door for almsfood. Seeing the monk, Tambadithika thought to himself, "Throughout my life, I have been executing thieves; now I should offer this food to the monk." So, he invited Sariputta to come in and respectfully offered the food. After the meal, Sirriputta taught him the Dhamma, but TambarlitIhika could not pay atten- tion, because he was extremely disturbed as he rec- ollected his past career as an executioner. This men- tal disturbance did not allow him to concentrate properly. Sariputta knew this, and in order to put him in a proper frame of mind, he asked Tambadithika tactfully whether he killed the thieves because he wished to kill them out of anger or hate, or simply because he was ordered to do so. Tambadithika answered that he was ordered to kill them by the king and that he had no ill will or wish to kill. 'If that is the case,' Sariputta asked, 'What wrong did you do?' Thus re-assured, his mind became calmer and he requested Sirriputta to continue his sermon. As he listened to the 48 A Manual of Peace: 38 Steps towards Enlightened Living EFTA01129150
Sivu 49 / 465
Dhamma attentively, his mind became tranquil and he developed the virtues of patience and un- derstanding. After the discourse, Tambadfithika accompanied Sariputta for some distance and then returned home. On his way home he died due to an accident. When the Buddha came to the congregation of the bhikkhus in the evening, they informed him about the death of Tambadfithika. When asked where Tambadathika was reborn, the Buddha told them that although Tambadfithika had com- mitted evil deeds throughout his life, because he comprehended the Dhamma, he was reborn in the Tusita deva world. The bhikkhus wondered how such an evil-doer could have such great benefit after listening to the Dhamma just once. To them the Buddha said that the length of a discourse is of no consequence, for one single sentence of the Dhamma, correctly understood can produce much benefit. Blessing Two: Associating with the Wise 49 EFTA01129151
Sivu 50 / 465
50 A Manual of Peace: 38 Steps towards Enlightened Living EFTA01129152
Sivu 51 / 465
Blessing Three: Expressing Respect to Those Worthy of Respect A. INTRODUCTION A.1 People Differentiated by their discretion As seen in the previous blessings, the brightness of a person's future relies on his ability to judge the difference between good and evil. If his judgement is faulty, there is no way he can make a success out of his life. Even though people may look superfi- cially similar, their standards of judgement can be so different. As human beings we are born equal — we all have a pair of hands and ten fingers — but some people use their hands to perform works that are useful to society while others think that their hands will become more famous as fists and go around punching up the neighbours for a living. In this Blessing we look at the third of three major in- fluences on our development of sound discretion — having the right sort of "role model" in our hearts. This blessing doesn't imply that we model ourselves on anyone or anything at all — but if we want to develop sound discretion we need to model ourselves (recognize and pay respect to) only those worthy of our respect. A.2 Effect of one's "hero" on one's discretion Hearing such terms as "paying respect", "express- ing respect" or "people worthy of respect", the casual reader might come to the premature conclu- sion that this blessing is irrelevant to our day and age. However, if we rephrase what we mean in modern terms, asking "Who is the hero of your heart — which celebrity do you model yourself on or dream of emulating?", the pertinence of this blessing will become much more immediate. When we are children and the horizons of our experience do not extend beyond the walls of our house, maybe our own parents represent all that we want to achieve in our lives. We try to play at being "grown-up" like our parents, imitating them in our play. If we are exposed to a good parental example, our idea of what we perceive as normal or ethical will develop quite accurately from an early age. However, if, for example, parents lie to their children often or beat them out of anger, then that comes to be what the child perceives to be the standard of "justice" in life. During one's teen years, when one's horizons extend beyond the home, the influence of construc- tive or destructive role models becomes stronger and stronger. These role models are over and above the influence of good or bad friends as studied in the previous two blessings. Look at some of the role models celebrities set for the youth of today and you can imagine some of the problems facing our impressionable youth of today. Supposing you plan to model yourself on Vincent Van Gogh, Kurt Cobain, Marilyn Monroe, Janis Joplin, Dylan Thomas, Jimi Hendrix, Elvis Presley, Jim Morrison, Keith Moon, F. Scott Fitzgerald, Ernest Hemingway or Brian Jones all of whom killed themselves at an early age, you might come to the conclusion that truly creative people are "too beautiful for this world". You might come Blessing Three: Expressing Respect to Those Worthy of Respect 51 EFTA01129153
Sivu 52 / 465
to the conclusion that creative writers drank be- cause they had to — or it was the "pressure of fame". Or that killing yourself is how to earn fame or emotionally blackmail others. We can overlook the insecure, grotesquely boring reality of these peoples' lives. We can rationalize away the brutal and banal nature of their addictions. We can for- give our heroes and we come to be able to forgive ourselves as well. It gives us an instant excuse to be irresponsible and indecent. We can say we're too beautiful for this world too. We can act like drugged children, crash our lives and drop out. The truth about someone like Vincent Van Gogh is that when he painted he was beautiful, but in other matters he was not. He was always encour- aging his emotions to work their dark magic. It's true that he ought to be admired while he had his paintbrush in his hand, but to be admired for his whole sorrowful life and to make a legend out of it is to confuse oneself. The problem for us as begin- ners on the initial steps of the Manual of Peace, as debutants only just beginning to pick up an ink- ling of what is good for our spiritual development and what is not, we don't yet have the ability to distinguish between the creative and destructive as- pects of someone's behaviour — therefore, when you are starting out on your sojourn of spiritual dis- covery, it's better to choose a role model who you can rely upon as an exemplar in all aspects of life. If you can choose a reliable role model for your- self: • you will accelerate your acquisition of Right View and Wisdom. • you will become less vulnerable to the influ- ence of fools • you will more easily be able to avoid associat- ing with fools • you will facilitate the spread of virtue in soci- ety and the world. • it will prevent you from becoming self-cen- tred or arrogant about your own virtues. • it will facilitate the development of mindfulness that is the precursor of wisdom. • it will add to your enthusiasm for self-devel- opment B. EXPRESSING RESPECT AND ITS PI RPOSE If you ask yourself what you automatically do, when you have a "hero" in your heart, on analysis, you find that you devote all your waking thoughts to them. We put their picture on the wall. When we speak about them, we only speak praise of them. we take every opportunity to learn their opinions and share them. Given the opportunity we try to meet with them and imitate what they do in their lives. Some people even go to the lengths of dress like them. All these are random components of an attitude we call "respect". Many of the behaviours are ways of "paying respect" or "expressing re- spect". B.1 What do we mean by "respect"? Respect means the attitude of looking for the posi- tive aspects of a person or an object and the effort to instill oneself with those same virtues. Such respect, in context of the Manual of Peace is for the aim of furthering one's spiritual development — it must not have any ulterior motive. It mustn't be like a judo player who raises someone up (in his own self esteem by flattering them) only to drop him onto the floor more easily. Some bosses blindly believe their subordinates' flattery is respect to the extent that they overlook the real state of affairs and end up getting fired. This latter case of expressing re- spect does not come from a mind of pure innocence which expects or demands nothing material in re- turn. True respect arises in response to someone's vir- tues. Something else which may look like respect but which is in fact an imposter is the intention to help someone in the expectation of gaining some- thing material in return. First comes the flattery, then comes the unrefusable request for this or that favour. Boyfriend praises girlfriend, saying how pretty she is, because he wants her to love him. He has an ulterior motive to get something in return. He's not interested per se in either her goodness or her prettiness. B.2 What do we mean by "expressing respect"? Expressing Respect means any polite and inten- 52 A Manual of Peace: 38 Steps towards Enlightened Living EFTA01129154
Sivu 53 / 465
tional action towards someone or something, both in their presence or behind their back, that is the device that demonstrates that one is really recollecting the virtues of that person or thing. £3 Purpose of Respect The reason behind paying homage to those worthy of homage is an extension of the reason for associ- ating with the wise. We have already said that we associate with the wise in the hope that they will help us to develop accurate discretion in things con- cerning virtue. It is to help us overcome the weak- ness in our make-up, that we tend too easily to for- get all the good and valuable things taught to us by our teachers and masters and parents or the mo- nastic community, the Lord Buddha, or from books we read. When you are taught how to meditate for half-an-hour per day (or to do any other good deeds), however, your memory doesn't seem to be so reliable. The first day, you sit for meditation for exactly half-an-hour — no more, no less. On the second day, you sit for only fifteen minutes — well, that's better than nothing. On the third day, you think that while you are chanting is actually a sort of meditation, so five minutes of true meditation is enough. On the fourth day it is especially humid, so you think that chanting is enough, no medita- tion today — after all, thousands of other people don't meditate, and they seem no worse off for it. By the fifth day you have entirely forgotten how to meditate for half an hour. It is for the reason that doing good deeds is so easy to forget that is the real reason for the need to pay homage. On the contrary, when it comes to being devious, or doing mischievous things, we remember the from the first time we're taught and never need to be taught again for the rest of our lives! We never forget how to play poker. We never forget how to shuffle a deck of cards. The real reasons behind paying homage areas fol- lows: 1. To give us a firm connection with the virtues of that person. Connecting up our thoughts with a person of virtue will elevate our own minds to the higher level of virtue of that person. 2. To practice expressing virtues so that in the fix- ture we might have the chance to gain a real ap- preciation of the virtues of that person. Whether we are an adult or a child, if our appreciation of the real depth of virtue of a does not really do justice to the depth of their virtue, expressing homage can help us to appreciate it. When we were only five or six years old and our parents took us to the temple they would make sure that we paid respect to the Buddha images. For the child, he cannot see beyond the clay or the brass of the image and might wonder what all the fuss is about. A child that is so young can have no appreciation of the real depth of the virtues of the Lord Buddha. Taken to the home of their old uncle, they are told to pay respect to their uncle. The child cannot distinguish the goodness of their uncle's character, but pays respect because he has been told to. At school, the child is told to pay respect to their teachers. The child might not be able to tell the real virtue of the teacher, be- cause the child's ability to comprehend is only limited. However, sometime in the future when we become so used to expressing our respect that we become used to it, the thought will eventu- ally occur to us to look for the reason. BA Three Types of Bowing Sometimes people confuse respect with expressing respect. However, if you express respect when your attitude is wrong you will not succeed in further- ing your spiritual progress. Consider the following examples: 1. Bowing out of obsequiousness: Some people bow just because everyone else does. Usually they bow reluctantly. They have no attitude of respect in their mind. Therefore, all they get for their ef- forts is a stiff feeling in their muscles. 2. Bowing out of peer-pressure: Some people only show respect in order to please the person they pay respect to, so that they can ask favours from that person, often for things which are not en- tirely honest or noble. 3. Bowing in search of wisdom: This refers to those who have an attitude of respect and who also Blessing Three: Expressing Respect to Those Worthy of Respect 53 EFTA01129155
Sivu 54 / 465
express their respect with the determination to practice themselves all the virtues exemplified by the object of their respect. An example of the sort of attitude in mind of someone who ben- efits from expressing respect is—supposing we bow three times to express respect towards the Buddha: 1. Mien we bow the first time: to reflect on the supreme wisdom of the Buddha which allowed him to see the existence of suffering, know the origin and the cessation of suffering and find a Path to the Cessation of Suffering — wis- dom arising from the Buddha's extended meditation mind until his mind had become sufficiently dear and bright to eradicate all de- filements of the mind. Following his exam- ple, we should also determinedly meditate until we can achieve the same wisdom as that of the Buddha. 2. When we bow the second time: to reflect on the supreme compassion of the Lord Buddha that instead of just keeping his wisdom to himself, he spent all his life teaching Dhamma to others so that they could become enlight- ened in his footsteps. Following his example, we should also find ways of being generous as a way of expressing our compassion to oth- ers. 3. When we bow the third time: to reflect on the supreme purity of the body, speech and mind of the Lord Buddha cultivated through his ex- tended practice of self-discipline. Following his example, we should also find ways of find- ing better ways to extend our own self-disci- pline so that we too can attain full purity of mind. B.5 Two sorts of Respect However, all four of these can be summarized un- der just two headings, that is: 1. Homage through gifts: remisapujil: this refers to all material forms of paying homage — whether it be putting your palms together in a gesture of respect or even speaking words of praise about a person. 2. Homage through practice: [patipatipuja] this means paying homage by doing as one is taught — for example, we pay respect to the Lord Bud- dha by doing as he taught. Thus, in practice, expressing respect has two major components. £5.1 Relative importance When we pay respect to the Lord Buddha, we should emphasise homage through practice, while homage through gifts should play only a support- ing role. As for paying respect to teachers who are still concerned with worldly matters (ie. king, par- ents, teachers, elders and boss, we have to empha- sise homage through gifts) while homage though practice plays only a supporting role. To give an example, if we are to meet up with our teacher and when we meet up with them all we have for them is the words,"I have put into prac- tice everything you have taught me". This would hardly impress the teacher. It would have been ap- propriate to have some sort of gift to give the teacher as well. Others go abroad and on the way back thinkof their teacher. They don't know what to get as a present for the teacher and so they get a bottle of liquor. In the end the result is that the teacher and the pupil sit down and drink liquor together. The more they drink, the more irritated they feel and end up fighting one another. When it gets to this point, that gift can hardly be counted as a token of respect any more. It is an unwelcome gift resulting from false view. C. PERSONAGES a OR 1 HY OF RESPECt The person worthy of respect, in its simplest terms is the wise one (as defined in the previous Blessing). The wise one in this context is someone whose sta- tus or position or level of existence is so high that it would be completely inappropriate for us to asso- ciate with them on equal terms or as peers. Exam- ples of such people include: C.1 Buddha The Lord Buddha (who is truly wise), 54 A Manual of Peace: 38 Steps towards Enlightened Living EFTA01129156
Sivu 55 / 465
C.1.1 Three worthy qualities of the Buddha For example, why we consider the Lord Buddha to be worthy of respect, and we find that it is because: I. His wisdom is so great that he could single- handedly attain enlightenment 2. His Compassion is so great that He sacrificed the rest of his life to teach the way for others to reach enlightenment as he had done. 3. His body, speech and mind were so pure (be- cause of the immaculateness with which he had kept the Precepts) that no one else in the world can compare — and for that reason we hold him in the highest of respect. To begin with we might not be able to appreciate the degree of his virtue, but after paying respect more and more, it makes our own mind more re- fined, gives us the ability to consider things in a constructive way and in the end, opening to us the innate wisdom that will allow us to appreciate that virtue. In any place, there are many things that are worthy of respect and many more things that are not worthy of respect. Thus, when deciding about the type of people who are worthy of respect, the subject of this Blessing, it is important to be able to distinguish one thing from the other. C.2 The monastic community and other clergy The monastic community 1Satigha] (who can be divided into those who are devoid of all defile- ment [ariyasanghaJ such as the arahants, the non-returners lanagamil, the once-returners Isakatagami] and the stream-enterers [sotapanct]; and the general monastic commu- nity who are striving to train themselves to- wards an end of all defilements Isammuti- safighab Although the latter may not yet have purged themselves of all defilements, they are abundant in virtue to a degree that it is innappropriate to associate with them as if they were our equals. If we associate with them, we should treat them as our superiors — i.e. with respect — at all times. Monks or clergy worthy of respect are those who exemplify, teach and discern virtue for us by fulfilling the following six duties: 1. restrain their congregation from evil; 2. encourage them to establish themselves in vir- tue: these two responsibilities are also the do- main of parents and teachers; 3. minister to them in kindness: this means spread- ing loving-kindness towards the congregation without exception for their happiness. They might also visit their supporters, together with their monastic fellows, in order to give those con- gregation members the chance to hear Dhamma teachings and have the opportunity to practice to practice generosity; 4. teach them new or beneficial things: One of the most important functions of the clergy is to en- courage study of the spiritual teachings amongst their congregation. Monks should have a large repertoire of teachings to give to the congrega- tion, teaching without repeating themselves, so that the congregation can have a broad knowl- edge of Dhamma knowledge, reinforcing their Right View and ability to be a teacher to them- selves [yonisomanasikara] in relation to find- ing the highest happiness in their lives; 5. clarify things they already know: if monks give Dhamma teachings they have already give to a particular group from the congregation, they should enlarge the subject in more detail than before, giving additional meaning to materials or explaining in further detail how the Dhamma can be applied for problem solving in everyday life; 6. show them the way to heaven: this monastic duty is particularly special in the system of the 'Six Directions' because no-one in any of the other social groups can do it in the monks' place. Those who are able to enter heaven must be those who live their lives in accordance with the noble code of Self-Discipline. This group consists of all forms of clergy who have an exclusively spiritual (rather than material) aim in life — namely monks in Buddhism, or priests, pastors or ministers for other religions. We hold them in respect, because they maintain their status through their high level of virtue. In conclusion, the responsibility of the clergy consists of training the Blessing Three: Expressing Respect to Those Worthy of Respect 55 EFTA01129157
Sivu 56 / 465
lay congregation to become Wise Ones or virtuous people —a noble duty indeed! Monks who are able to practice all six of these duties to their comple- tion are of inestimable value to society and the world — they are worthy of respect both by men and angels alike. C.3 Virtuous monarchs Monarchs worthy of respect are those established in the Tenfold Virtues of a Monarch; C.4 Our Parents Our Parents and upstanding members of society. Our parents are wise ones. We should treat them with respect. Anything less would be inappropri- ate. C.5 Our Teachers Teachers and masters established in right view. In this context we should mention the two identify- ing features of a teacher's duties, both of which he needs to fulfil in order to qualify for the respect of his students. These two duties are: 1. The duty to explain (i.e. teach a subject in theory) 2. The duty to exemplify (especially the moral us- age of the subject he teaches) If he fails to perform either of these duties his teach- ing is no more than daylight robbery of his pupils. If he gives good explanations but his personal be- haviour is no example for his students to follow (for example he teaches 'do as I say not what I do' and tells the class that liquor is evil while spend- ing all his spare time inebriated at the bar, he is noth- ing more than a mercenery teacher. If he both explains the theory well and is a good example to his students, he is a person worthy of respect. C.6 Virtuous employer Virtuous employers are also worthy of respect. It is hard to find bosses with virtue, so when we find one, we should not hesitate to pay them respect. We may still be unable to be as virtuous as them, so we ought to pay them respect, in order that their virtues might never be far from our minds — in- stead of being tempted to do something devious, we will be less tempted because we feel ashamed after the seeing the good example set by our boss. Also we will be more ashamed that anything we do wrong might reflect badly on our boss's good reputation. This is the value of having a virtuous boss. It keeps us on the straight and narrow until such time that we have reliable discretion for our- selves. I). Oa WORTHY OF RESPECT There are certain classes of objects identified by the Lord Buddha as worthy of respect, and these are objects associated with people worthy of respect i.e. the Lord Buddha, the Sangha, monarchs, parents, teachers and bosses. There are two categories of such objects, pagodas (and their contents) and teachings: 13.1 Pagodas D.1.1 Four Types of Pagoda The Buddha enumerated four types of pagoda worthy of respect: 1. A relic pagoda: this is a pagoda containing the relics of a Buddha, a paccekabuddha, an arahant or a universal monarch. After the cremation of a truly virtuous person there are pearl-like relics left behind in the ashes. In keeping with the teaching of the Buddha, these are collected by the faithful and are paid homage to, by Bud- dhists, not only with candles and incense, but by enshrining them in small pagodas. 2. Paribhoga Cetiya: These include the Four Holy Sites connected with the life of the Lord Bud- dha: the place where He was born, enlightened, where He gave His first sermon and where He passed away into Parinirvana. The Lord Buddha called these four places His Paribhoga Cetiya and taught that all Buddhists of following genera- tions should visit these holy sites if they had the chance because it would awaken them to the urgent need to get down to practice. Many peo- ple who have been to visit the Holy Sites have discovered that their inspiration to practice has 56 A Manual of Peace: 38 Steps towards Enlightened Living EFTA01129158
Sivu 57 / 465
is strengthened from the feeling of going back to a time when they were in the presence of the Lord Buddha himself. This is the reason why these four sites are worthy of worship. 3. Dhamma Cetiya: This is a Cetiya that contains Dhamma teachings such as books of the Tipitaka or other Scriptures. 4. Uddesika Cetiya: This is a Cetiya that contains Buddha Images or images of His Noble Disci- ples. Objects worthy of respect in this category also include the requisites belonging to monks — whether it be robes or bowl, all of the monks' requisites are worthy of respect. 13.2 Dhamma Teachings A fifth sort of object worthy of respect are spiritual teachings and their sources. These may include the Teachings of the Lord Buddha, of members of the monastic community, of kings, of our parents and elders, of our teachers and masters, of our boss and the teachings of the wise with whom we associate. The teachings of all six categories of the wise men- tioned above are the manifestation of the virtue of those people and should never be taken in vain. Making a mockery of such teachings will under- mine our earnestness in putting those teachings into practice. If we lack earnestness in putting the teach- ings into practice, we reduce our chance of ever un- derstanding those teachings. In the absence of un- derstanding, there remains only ignorance and false view. Thus any of the objects mentioned above should not be used for mockery or for fun. To treat these things without reverence robs them of their sanc- tity and when we come to study them we will over- look their depth or subtlety. An example of this might be the man who goes to receive Five Precepts from the monk at the temple and keeps the Pre- cepts so well for the first few days. Later he joins in with one of his friends makes fun of the Precepts and says,"Oh the Precepts? Aren't they for keep- ing one for each day of the week and weekends off?" Even if he still keeps his Precepts, the effect of these words is to gradually undermine the man's inspiration to keep them. The same principle goes for photographs or pictures of the Buddha, of monks, of the king, of our parents or teachers. Such photographs should not be left ly- ing about or used without reverence. Chanting books shouldn't be left lying about either or folded up and shoved in the back pocket of one's trousers. They shouldn't be put down on a dusty surface and other things should not be placed on top of them. In conclusion, those worthy of respect are the wise who are established in virtue, or those who by their social standing are too high up for us to be able to associate with personally or as peers. Apart from these six categories of person, objects which should be treated with respect include the requisites they use as a way of recollecting the virtues of that per Even though that person may already have passed away, treating their belongings with respect will help us to maintain high-mindedness and Right View concerning that person. 113 Educational Objects Also we shouldn't forget that all books which con- tain Dhamma should be treated with respect. The ancients would be very particular even about the notebooks in which we have taken note of Dhamma sermons. They forbade us from throwing such note- books, stepping over them, putting them in low down places or tearing out pages — because all of these things would constitute disrespect to the teachings themselves. If we were to lack respect towards the Dhamma, then when we come to con- sider Dhamma Teachings for which the meaning is very subtle, we will be unable to fathom the mean- ing and our understanding of the Dhamma will be destroyed and we will be left with nothing more than our own ignorance. 114 Objects not worthy of respect Correspondingly, we must be careful not to pay re- spect to things not worthy of respect. In brief, there are four categories of things we should avoid idol- ising or paying respect to: 1. People not worthy of Respect: This means not idolizing fools, and not supporting them or prais- ing them — no matter how high in rank they might be. Blessing Three: Expressing Respect to Those Worthy of Respect 57 EFTA01129159
Sivu 58 / 465
2. Objects not worthy of respect: This means not idolizing pictures, sculptures, works, possessions or tools of fools. 3. Objects which lead to foolishness: This means not idolizing things like pictures of models, sing- ers or sportsmen who lack virtue or advertising for "roads to ruin" such as alcohol. We shouldn't use these sort of things to decorate our homes. 4. Objects which lead to gullability: This means not idolizing things which promote superstition such as "holy trees", "holy mountains", "spirit houses" etc. E. RE PRAIA 'tam or PAYING RESPECT £1 Erpressing respect with body, speech and mind Respect can be paid through the channels of body, speech or mind. 1. Physical Respect: Physically paying respect means the various polite manners that we dem- onstrate towards someone in their presence, such as standing up when they come into the room, or sitting politely when in front of them. Even if you are not in their presence, you should still show physical respect towards those worthy of virtue even if you are not in their presence but are in the presence of their photograph, their sculpted image — such as a Buddha Image or a photograph of your teaching master. We should show our respect by not pointing our feet to- wards such an image, and even if we are lying down to sleep — pointing our head towards the image instead of our feet; 2. Verbal Respect Homage through the channel of speech includes the speaking, chanting or sing- ing of praises of one worthy of homage, rather than gossipping maliciously about them; 3. Mental Respect Homage through the channel of the mind means recollecting the teachings of one worthy of homage to the degree that they inspire us. We might recollect what that person has taught us in the way of good deeds. We might also consider the good character and virtues ex- emplified (but not taught) by that person. Both of these are homage through the channel of the mind; E.2 How to Express Respect Many people misunderstand paying respect as bun- dling together a lotus, candles and incense, laying it before the object of respect and bowing down three times. Paying respect in this way is not incor- rect, but it is not the whole story. Paying respect that is complete in all respects must exhibit four factors: 1. Physical token of respect isakkaraj: This refers to a gift which is an expression of respect. It is something we must prepare in advance and which is presented during the act of paying re- spect. Such a token of respect differs for differ- ent situations and different categories of persons worthy of respect — for example, flowers, in- cense and candles are worthy tokens of respect for paying respect to the Buddha, monks or teachers. Clothes or bedclothes might be more worthy tokens of respect for your parents. Nei- ther of these tokens of respect are suitable as the sort of gift you might take with you when visit- ing distinguished persons of social standing. Nor would they be suitable as the sort of gift you bring back with you for your friends when you have been away on holiday. Even money can be a token of respect. If your teacher has been putting in extra hours out of the kindness of his heart, giving up his time to give you tutorials at home, giving him money as a gift would not be out of place, and in this respect would be con- sidered a token of respect, not a payment. An- other consideration for tokens of respect is that they should be prepared in advance. To leave a bucket of cut flowers, no matter how big the bucket is, in the middle of the main temple pavillion would hardly be considered an act of respect. Any token of respect should be prepared with care and precision and be both clean and well organized. 2. Gesture of respect Ivandana]. this refers to ges- tures which express respect such as bowing or prostration or praise or chanting praise. Morn- ing and evening chanting can be counted as vandana. Even recollection of what one has been taught by the wise or one's teacher can be 58 A Manual of Peace: 38 Steps towards Enlightened Living EFTA01129160
Sivu 59 / 465
counted as uandana. 3. Attitude of respect [mananaj: This refers to an attitude of respect. Respect consists of the stems 're' which means again and 'spect' which means to re-examine a person (for their good points). Given that all people except the Buddha are made up of a mixture of both good and bad then we have to look for the good points in people. Taking these good points, apart from noticing these good points, part of respect is to praise them for these good points and use them as a good example to model ourselves upon. 4. Content for the object of respect[garuketra]: this refers to an attitude of concern about the well- being of the person who is worthy of respect and recollection of the good deeds and virtues of that person. All of these four components comprise the way of paying respect. £3 Consequences of Not Paying Respect to those worthy of homage If those held in high respect do not behave in a fit- ting way, many sorts of harm are brought on the individual, interpersonal and social levels. To take the clergy as an example, if members of the monas- tic community are undisciplined and do not cher- ish their congregation according to the advice of the Buddha, the harm that will come to the congre- gation can be concluded on three levels: 1. Losing a sense of responsibility for their own human dignity: If clergy lack self-discipline and don't fulfil their duties towards their congrega- tion as prescribed by the Lord Buddha, the first level of disaster which will happen to them is that the congregation will lose their sense of re- sponsibility for their own human dignity — this loss giving rise (at the minimum) to the follow- ing three undesirable symptoms: 1. Breakdown of self-discipline: Society will degen- erate to the point where the majority of peo- ple do not keep the Five Precepts and do not even understand what keeping the Precepts means. This will increase the incidence of so- ciety of people taking advantage of each other. When taking advantage of each other becomes the the norm, especially for those in positions of authority, the effects will have repurcussions on a national scale — therefore, citizens must unite in preventing those who don't respect the Five Precepts from being put in positions of power; 2. Those seeking ordination are of low quality: Low- quality ordinands burden their preceptors with problems — it is hard to train them at all. If clergy are unable to develop purity of body, speech and mind, they will undermine the existing faith of the congregation — ulti- mately destroying the religion; 3. Transcendental attainment becomes becomes in- creasingly inaccessible: The highest aim of those who ordain is to attain Nirvana. Howeveti if those who ordain are of low quality and are difficult to train, there will be a continuous deterioration in the capability of the monas- tic community to the point where they will no longer be able to reach any sort of tran- scendental attainment. When there are no re- ligious exemplars to look up to, the congre- gation will become more and more firmly entrenched in False View — more and more ignorant of Dhamma teachings, self-discipline — with some of the most serious repurcussions for social chaos; 2. Losing a sense of responsibility for the human dignity of others: If clergy lack self-discipline and don't fulfil the duties towards their congrega- tion as prescribed by the Lord Buddha, the sec- ond level of disaster which will happen to them is that the congregation will lose their sense of responsibility for the human dignity of others — this loss giving rise (at the minimum) to the following three undesirable symptoms: 1. Verbal abuse of clergy and monks: Once the con- gregation no longer realize the value to soci- ety of clergy and monks, misunderstanding the duty and lifestyle of the clergy, the public will abuse the clergy shamelessly (as is hap- pening currently in Thailand); Blessing Three: &pressing Respect to Those Worthy of Respect 59 EFTA01129161
Sivu 60 / 465
2. Lack of financial support for clergy and monks: Swayed by the often unjustified abuse of clergy in the media, the faith of the public de- teriorates, and with it the support with which they should provide the clergy — religions such as Buddhism can only survive through the voluntary support of the congregation, and without it, there will soon be no clergy left, and consequently no-one to perpetuate the religion; 3. Congregation is left without any true refuge: Hav- ing dismantled their religion by their own ne- glect, when the public find themselves in dire straits, they will be without a refuge, lacking the ability to be a teacher to themselves, they will resort to superstition or animism. 3. Losing a sense of responsibility for economic fairness in society at large: If clergy lack self- discipline and don't fulfil the duties towards their congregation as prescribed by the Lord Buddha, the third level of disaster which will happen to them is that the congregation will lose their sense of responsibility for economic fair- ness in society at large — this loss giving rise (at the minimum) to the following three undesirable symptoms: 1. Total enfatuation with the Six Roads to Ruin: In a society of deteriorating morals, it will become more and more common for people either to eke out their living via, or be enslaved by the consequences (such as debt and disease) of Roads to Ruin such as drugs, gambling, pros- titution, entertainment and underground lot- teries. 2. Desecration of religious property and establish- ments: The Roads to Ruin are part of the vi- cious circle of poverty. Some people try to al- leviate their poverty by theft —and religious property is an easy target of plunder. Some encroach on temple grounds in pursuit of their livelihood. In Thailand this practice is becom- ing more and more widespread, especially because it has been legally condoned by bi- ased legislators; 3. Embezzlement of religious donations: Some peo- ple like to extract some sort of 'commission' from the funds they manage to raise for the temple (in accordance with the phrase "half for the temple, half for the temple commit- tee'!) In the present day, howevec. some legis- lators try to go further than this by giving the government the right to control temple funds directly! Problems concerning not paying respect to those worthy of respect can be summarized down to two main points: 1. Obvious social problems: Easily seen is public deterioration in morality as a result of ignorance of virtue. Such people like to say they have lost interest in virtue because they see so many ex- amples of hypocrisy. For the same reasons they withhold financial support for spiritual causes and some go further, overtly making legislative changes necessary for the dismantling of the re- ligious establishment; 2. Covert social problems: The covert social prob- lems mostly originate from the hypocrisy amongst those who should be behaving as ex- emplars of virtue. Considered with wise reflec- tion, the problems might be analyzed as such: 1. Good exemplars are sometimes unable to pass on their knowledge to others because 1. the public are not interested to learn from the clergy— all they want are the material trappings of spirituality and virtue such as holy water and amulets; 2. the public undervalue the teachings on vir- tue they receive because they think they are already highly qualified in academic sub- jects — so thinking, they consider their abil- ity in vocational subjects makes earning money more important than knowing spir- itual teachings. 1. 1U41.S1RA11N E EXAMPLES In order to illustrate the results of paying respect to those worthy of respect here are five examples, the second of which is an example of homage through gifts: 60 A Manual of Peace: 38 Steps towards Enlightened Living EFTA01129162