EFTA00230193

Page 1 of 1 
Match 20, 2011 
To whom it may cencetu: 
I served u s U.S. Attaney for the Southern District of Florida from 2005 through 2009. Over S 
past weeks. L have read much toga:ding Mr. balmy Epsteto. Some appears Imo. some appears 
distorts. I :bought it appropriate to preside tome background, with two c.aseaus: (i) tirAer 
Justice Department guidelines, I comet discos; privileged intone communications among 
Department attorneys and (ii) I no longs have access to the original documents, and as the 
mama is now nearly 4 years old, the ptaision of memory is reduced.
Thu Epstein matter was originally presented b the Palm Bath County Mate Attornoy. him 
:Reach Police alined that Epatein molawfully hired underage high-school females ic provide him 
sexually lewd and erotic massages. Police sought felony charge that would have resulted in a 
term of in iptisoretteur Aceorchng so press reports, however. in 2006 the State Attorney, in pit 
due to cancans regarding the quality of tbe evidence, agreed to charge Epstein only with one 
count of aggravated assault with no Sat to cameo felony. That chase would have resulted 
ifs no jail twee, no requirement to master as a sexual offender and no restitution for the underage 
at al police were dissatisfied with the State Attorney's coughcsions, and rrquested a federal 
invest/peon Federal authorities received dm State's evidence and engaged io additional 
investigalioo. Prosecutors weighed Sc quality of the evithmee and the litahhood for success at 
teal. With a federal case, thew were two additional considaations. First, a federal criminal 
prosecution requires that the crime be moot than loyal; it most have an interstate nexus. Second, 
as 'be new was initially charged by the state. the federal responsibility is. to ante extent, to 
Lees-stop stoic autinu Mr.; to ensure that those is nu ntisootetage of junige, and not to alias 
prosecute federally that which has already been charged at die state level. 
After considering the quality of the evidence and the 04 tional COttaideratinsi, prosecutors 
conetoded that the state charge was anstilkient. In early summer 2007, the prosecutors and 
agents ea this cats met with Mr. Epecires annuity, Roy Black. Mr. Mack n. perhaps best known 
for his successful defense of William Kennedy Smith. The prosecutors presented Tspstelo a 
choice: plead to mote serious state felony clews (that wooed mutt in 2 mass' Imprisonment, 
regiswation as a sexual offender, and restitution :or the victims) or ctsc recs.. ne for a federal 
-felony alai. 
What followed was a yea-long assault on the prosecution and the prosecnters. I ass the word 
annuli intentionally. as the defense m this cast was more aggressive than soy which 1, or the 
prosecutors in my effigy, had prevmuslyenRannered. Mr. Epstein hired an army of 'Zvi 
superstars: Harvard Professor Alan Dashowitz, former Judge and Mete Pepperdine Law Dean 
Kameth Starr, fauna Deputy Ass:staor z teePresident and abmi Kirkland a: Ellis Partner Jay 
Loranvim, and stymie others, incleirry4 prosecutors ?dm had formally worked in the U.S. 
hap://www.tdbimg.com/files/2011/03/24/img-article-embed---epstein---acosta-letter-page-1... 5/6/2011 
EFTA00230193

4 
I 
Page 1 of I 
Attorney'r. Office and in the Child Exploitation ad Obscenity Seedan of the Justice Dept-Meat 
Defense auomeys nest requested a meeting with me cc aiallenge the prosecution and the terms 
previously- presented by the prosecutors in their mating with Mr. Black The prosecution team 
and I met with defense counsel in Fall 200% and I reaffirmed the office's position: two years. 
teg iteration and its tnation, or zit'. 
Over the next several months, the defense taws pesetad aipmett aaer argument claiming that 
(deny criminal proceedings spins: Epstein were onsuppeced by the evidence and Lacked a basis 
in law, and that the office's insistence on jail-bathe was roosivated by:. zeal to nvetcharp a man 
melds because he is vrealthy. They bolstered their arguments with legal opinions from well 
!mown legal expert.;; One member of the defense team roamed me that the offices excess zeal in 
Forcing a good mars to ae.e done in jail alight be the sante of 2 book if wo comirmed is 
prozned with this matt My office syoterratically considead and rejected each argument, and 
when we did, myoffices decisionswas appealed to Washington. As 10 the warning, I ignored 
it 
The defense amp. war not limited so legal issuer. Defense counsel investigated iadis:dual 
prosecutors and their fanatics, loo6dnj tbr personal peccadilloes that may provide a basis for 
distFultfl000rt. DitquahlYint alwoteeutOr is an effective (though tartly used) strmegy, as 
ehmtnating the individuais Meet familiar with the facts and thus most qualified to take a case to 
trial harms Itkchltool for success. Defense tame tried to disqualify at least two moacutors. : 
carefully reviewed, and then rejected, them arguments. 
Despite tins army of attorneys, (beelike held 6= to the taints film marsated to Sir. Black to 
the original meeting On lune 30, 2008, after yes another last minute appeal CO Washington D.C. 
was Natal. Epstein pled guilty in state COWL He was to serve t8 maths imprisonment, 
regimes as a sexual offender foe life and provide restitution to the victims 
Some may feel that the prosecution shadd Lace been tougher. Evidence that hoe cone to 
duce 2007 may encourage that view. Many victims have shift spoken ow, ailing detailed 
slaterr.entr in civil cases seeking damages. Physical evidence has since been diSe0Vered Had 
these additional statements and evidence been known, dmoutcome tray have been different. But 
they were not known to us at the tune. 
A pisseention deernon must be based an admissible facts known at the time. In eases of tins 
Type, those are unusually difficult because victims are frigtfrial and often decline to testify or if 
they do speak. they give couttadiaory stasoments. Our judgment in this case, based on the 
evidence lainwn at the time, was that it nut better to have a billionaire serve time in jail, register 
as a at offender and pay his victims rest fain than nisi a vial with a redu:mdhkelihood of 
;access. I appealed that judgment then, and based on the slate of the law as it then stood and the 
evident known at that time. I emilld ammon thin judgment again. 
EPstcnes utatmon. whale in smite woody, nowise reay encourage the view that the office 
should have ban tougher. Epstein appears to have received highly unusual teannent while in 
jail. Akhoush due sena oteusdlnement in a state prison are a matter appropnerely left to the 
http://www.tdbimg.com/files/2011/03/24/img-article-embed—secret-epstein--acosta-letter-... 5/6/2011 
EFTA00230194

. 
------------ -------
Page 1 of 1 
Stale Of Flende, and not farad stake nits. withoot &alit, the manned that he teccval while 
in mate custody undermined the purpose Ma jail sentetec 
Some may alto believe that the proseolanou should have beat tougher in retaliation foe the 
defense's tudes. The defense. arguably, oda) hided to negotiate in good faith. They would 
Sato coneessioos as pan Ma negotiation and agree to proceed, only to change then minds, and 
appeal Ow office's position to Wasaingion. The itwestigadoes Ism the family Lives of individual 
ptoscculors were. in my opinion, waded rot 2$ were its accusations of bias ad:
 
CT 
miseundud against loditakkial prosecutors. At ti2145, same prosecutor felt that we should just 
roa to true:. and at tithes I felt that Oustration myself Whin was right in the rust nwtiotg, 
however, remained right incapostive of Amble tactics. Individus Is have a coruhutthsoi ries to 
a defence. The aggressive exercise of that right should not be punished, not should a defense 
oounsds taccitis. oftbeirrigbt to appeal a U.S. Attorney to Washington, D.C. Prosecutors must 
be cateInt not to allow frasnation and anger with defense counsel to influence their judgment. 
After the plea,  recap swervingsera-al phoce cats. One was fiwn the FBI Special Atoll-In-
Charge. He called so offer conpatulations He had been at many of the meetings roweling this ' 
=se. He ww aware of the tunics of the <terms; and he called to praise elf prosecutors for 
holding Eras against the hbs of Messrs. Ef.ack, Derabowitz, Lefkowitz and Shirr. It was a proud 
tuomc
. I also intend calls cc conummicattons from Messrs. Dershowitz. Lefirowith and 
Starr. I had known a three individuals previously, from my lime in law school and at Rockland 
&Ellis lc the raid 90s. They all sought to make peace. ­ agreed to talk and meet wide each of 
them oder Eµ ten pins guilty, as I think it important that proserntots battle &false attorneys in 
a use ad then move cm. I hate trod, yet I comps that has bent difficult to do fully in this case. 
The horom Inie is this: Mr. Jeffrey Epstein, a billionaire, served time in jail and n MAY a 
niiatered tee Offellittt. He has been required to pay his victims restitution, then,: rositetion 
clearly =not coenoeasate for the clime. Aod we bow moth more today about b is corm 
because the "turns have come forward to speak oat. Prams may diagreo vdth the prosecutorial 
Padsietats made in this care, but duos individuals ate not the ones who at the lime niviowed thu 
evidenceavailable for trial and assessed the likelihood of success. 
Respectfully, 
R. Alexander AeOsta 
Format U.S. Attorney 
Sothern District of Florida 
http://www.tdbimg.cornifiles/2011/03/24/img-article-embed--secret-epstein---acosta-letter-... 5/6/2011 
EFTA00230195

1
Jeffrey Epstein attorney Roy Black denies allegations in letter by ex-U.S. Attorney Alexa... Page 1 of 2 
Regsler Nos I Stain, Ewell swivel-on 
VoNier. yby C,iM1 
Sawn. 
Renew 
CLASSIFIEDS I REAL ESTATE I DINING 
oPeciAt. seCnONS
KOWIE I NMVS I SOCACV I CUNNESS I ARTS I MP ON I OSIVAR1E5 I CFINIDN I lr-STILES I HOME I LOGGIA I SSINT SPOTS I SLOGS I ADVERTISE I 
I
CONTACT 
Electronic Edition Now Available! 
Click Here To Subscribe 
Horny > Palm Beach keen 
Jeffrey Epstein attorney Roy Black denies allegations in letter by ex-U.S. 
Attorney Alexander Acosta 
Acorn lap 1bl M.I. ; 
Pang par RATER LT 
Amu° Op 3 Al 
Lt.;:pri 
Late WOO svOntaa VOW 
in sows sloth, * mined on* 
*ening an Pain CINth 
Jul* walirleCei MICAO0 
Iayauw Nes yaws pol•Wno 
on dm; Gorr 
Lane, Wall'', Palm Ouch 
tuber on IAEA% ollAdv.33 
Dam. Cusses kern imbed 
ad fa Sand Monte tided M 
gran New Fewnclabaa ride. 
Alvialaw. • vslins• (wawa 
JAUM  mare MS. hasa-leow 
cos pore easy 40% snooty 
at sudwelicr 
By WC HE LE DARGAN 
OAST IRASSIAFF WRITER 
Updblet 921 a.m. Wednesday. Math 30. 2011 
Pastes 7:24 pas Tseadat March 29.2011 
Ewan I 
Pant I 
Sure II 
ewer Tyr 
Attorney Roy Black Is cesputirg deans that he. and ober attorneys 
representing Jeffrey Speech. pried Into federal prosecutors' penscnal 
lives in attempting to cesqually then, from invesligetdra the belionaire 
sex offender. 
Plods also denies Epsilon's a:annoys -negotiated In tied fa Or writ 
attempting to reach an agreement with federal prosecators. 
In a written response Tuesday to the Palm Beath Da0y Norm, Slack 
disputes claims made against Epsleirrs defense team by former U 
Allerney Alexander Acosta. Those and cah01 ollegebtthe by ACOSTA 
were °entailed in a tteee-page letter printed Friday in the online 
pule :radon The Daily Boast. 
Acosta was the U.S. Magnin for the Southern District of Florida at 
the time Epstein was bans Investigated ch federal charges related to 
IndIMPle Sex crimes with mew girls Black, the Man attorney oho 
succeesfully defended William Kennedy Smith sgelne rape charges. 
was part of Epaten's legal dream learn. 
Epstein was neva: charged Mb a federal arse. He and his 
*HOMO'S alma a deal with federal prosecutors. which was Geared 
in a non.preeecut.th agmernenl. According to the agreement. 
Epstein had to plead pity to two state charges. register as a lifelong 
sox °fonder and servo IS malths in jail. Mho successfully 
compbted tab lama and served one-year Oft:robs:ion, then 
Epstein would not be prosecuted on federal chregee ae they related 
to approximately 30 to 10 viers 
In a written response lo the Daily News. Slack said, We de prowl 
argument after argument why a mosso federal prosecution against 
Mr. Edelen was utaipportod by the evidence. We detailed the so 
called evidence during many meetings wrath prosecutors and agoras. 
'We were gate candid ll disclosing all the evidence we had gathered 
in our investigation and t berme we made a ccrencthg Case why 
charges were not appropriate I ma behove that today' 
According to Ameba, now dean of Me FIcelde International Universely 
College of taw, tadatal prosecutors and &gents met with Stack on the 
summer of 2007. ThO prosecutors priberled EpStein a Cheer): plead 
duper to stale felony charges tomalley In two yams Imprisonn ent. 
registaticn as a sex oleander end meal ton for the velIMS or 
prepare for a federal Sony trat 
What followed, Acosta said, was that Epstein's defense team 
munched a yearlong Assuan on the prosecution and the proseculors. 
1 use the word assault intentenally. as 11,3 defense in this owe wee 
more aggressNe than any with l. or the prosecutors h myorsce. 
had previously encountered Acosta sae in his letter. 
Anthrg the legal superstars' of Stettin's defense teem: Harvard 
prolemor Nan Dustmen:, Kenneth Starr. Jay Ledvants and several 
others. including prosecutors who had formally worked in the U.S. 
Attorney's Office and in be chid Explottelon and Obscenity Section 
of the Justice Department. 
g.STO 0 Web 
Web Sewell by YAHOO. 
uoll1S/UP 
rinr I 
by 
Shannon Donnelly 
Find us en Casebook 
Palm Beach Dolly News 
Ina 
1}M pate late Palm Death Daly News. 
enema ammo,
MOST :ASCENT ALBUMS 
•
7G a1 
••• 
•Tyr M. 
&abort nesph••• Ra-••••,e; 
COnflopelen 
air Mk., co, s 
Mooch. 
Cestmrity Con 
nnvilotiVerren 
PIMPS, 
1.1•••Cnos 
Alas 
http://www.palmbeachdailynews.com/news/jeffrey-epstein-attorney-roy-black-denies-allega... 5/6/2011 
EFTA00230196

- ------- -----
Jeffrey Epstcin attorney Roy Black denies allegations in letter by ex-U.S. Attorney Alexa... Page 2 of 2 
Acosta sale that one member of ule defense team warned Nm 'the 
office's excess zeal il forcing a good man to serve time in jail might 
be the sub)ecl of a boot II we continued to proceed wet ene wino** 
Black said he's never hoard ' ,won* mentbn wreing a took about the 
Epelein cue 'Mt Acosta clams we negotiated n bad faith by 
appealing to the Dewing« of Juetco in Wastivion' Black said 
"Any person under investigabon by a Unite States attorney. 
mearing any of Ina 9.4 such offices in the country, has the right to 
seek review by the Dopalment of Justice ond it fl so molded for in 
thee manual. Thus I cannot imagine Invoking this right cede be 
construed as bad faith 
in our syster) of justice, people are given the right of appeal and 
there should be no implication of wrong doing by oxtecieing 
'Finely Mr Area mentions we looked for ponawl Noosed-Mtn of 
proseadOrti.' BIM* sae. am not sure whet he refers tO b t MSS 
never happened. We cad point out misconduct and ower-reeching by 
carbon people InwoNed m the investigation. Not only is theft notrang 
wrong with this but it is a necessary part cl the process. There will 
always be people who abuse the great power of tho gave:newd and 
we can not Stand by silently when 0 occurs' 
the nomprosecuacn agreement was sealed in Epstein 's state felony 
Ale until yams Standen successfully argued to make the Occurrent 
public in September 2009. 
Vic.: up. 
pogo 
1 l d 
nor/mod . 
More fin MIN*. 
CC:IdMEWS 
Comments an closed 
N" 
rØ 
WT-41, 11:• 
Mtn 
ADVVRIMe 
t4.40 DO,
n.Yf 
YMIS 
Arta Cdierats 
=MN 
insilicir 
300VCI,C06), 
Nor 
MI••••••-ameh 
!SON 
iii. 
r..I N... 
I... Cw pine 
iipur.i.14 
M Co cii 
0, 01131 
el,OCI 
I 
NZ., 
Lennie. 
COL-WIWI 
:Seth L 
1...liNS »Itic,Eik. 
hoe 
Lab...1mi~ 
DOMMAC• 
!Wm.". err... 
,11.4p 6749 
LIPUTYUI 
Saguia. 
{
0..(w.% 
wMnrnr 
raid 
Iris, Mu" 
Pia 
~WI VS 
S 
"renal 
REAL WAYS 
~scar J tor 1 Nimbus ~Nee by ma% PsetBentCollIthemidetc. tat «St tot "a. clou S 
aO,nmont mute rem& 
l'aliPSEPPCJINI Mein COIn i PnVap POICS I Al^l Wr Si* 
http://www.palmbeachdailynews.com/news/jeffrey-epstein-attorney-roy-black-denies-allega... 5/6/2011 
EFTA00230197

Yeffiey Epstein attorney Roy Black denies allegations in letter by ex-U.S. Attorney Alexa... Page 1 of 2 
Rapar Ina :Strip in I Etna praiunos 
faddy, Ma P. 
ratan 
anon 
CLASSIFIEDS I REAL ESTATE I a NINO I SPECIAL SECTPONS I 
i Car I MOOS I Kt ZTY I UUS aSS I ARM I .4.51ilYPN I i3BniAITE3 I Diana I LIFFSTaTS I HOME å IOWA I all« SHOTS I OLOGS I ADVERTISE I 
I 
US 
Electronic Edition Now Available! 
Clidc Here To Subscribe 
Homo 5 råm 
Plena 
Jeffrey Epstein attorney Roy Black denies allegations In letter by ex-U.S. 
Attorney ~Gander Acosta 
 
 
jpegåreni ems I 
ado 
Au.* aye I 
Anna/ per 2 ATM( 
Appal 069. 3 Ai Nlii
I na 
awna niacin 
biX4 ;Kam° yasinelsoiiie 
many e: Mesa tar-ii 
illiPONAIMC1/4
iotopo Kano ymin petba)n 
on ding dare. 
limns Dnnt ra Pam Bean 
hula,  
d nn, nc. 
Orris, aysku Karr cake 
SuPini Secunty Mane in 
Dave Ian Finadanun Oleo 
AN•anlulnrWna awing 
nigh; rung legal loagan... 
arb plan Pat says O. rinli 
P: Paltionte 
«maven Pa in-
I 
lased 
Lees ryas 
Accord-mg to the agreement. aerial,  COW have redeked 10« MOM 
year if comic ed on federal &woes In eddlecr the aeroneons let 
often hook for any of those past Wilton 
'Sono feel the prosecution should have been tougher: Acosta Said 
in his letter. adding het violas' ensamrus and undefiled 'rewscal 
evidence' had been discovered since then. He stales that had those 
ratio's been known m 2007, To outcome 'nay have teen efferent 
'Ourmagnum in sus cage, based on the evidence known m the tree, 
was that it was tenor to have a bilronaire serve jail time. register as 
a sex offender and pay he victim reellheon than risk a trial with a 
reduced likelihood of success: 
Waal' attorneys Bred Edwards arid Pal Cassel are seeing lo get 
me non-prosecution agreement overturned. saying the U.S. 
Attorney's Oros violated the Crime Victims' Rghts Act by not 
notirjring victims before striking the deal. 
Epstein has contslentlasy stated mom tel two dozen lawsuits and 
claims from minor girka, all wet similar allegations: They were 
recruited to perform sexually charged massages mutter venous sex 
acts en Epstein, ter which they were paid 
Epstein, St served 13 months of en 18-month state sentence In a 
wows wing of the Palm Beech County Stockade. Ho uras 33OWei2 
Cal on work release ses days a vitek up lo 10 hours a day. 
During his rafter of homo conflnemiml In his Palm goad,
mansion, Epstein was slowed to travel out of state on his Ovate 
Plano to New York and to his private island in he Villein Islands, 
according lo probation records. 
Regarding Epstema Incarceration and probation. Acosta sad. 
tPeteln appears to have received hghly unusual treatment white in 
jai. Although the terms of confinement ina slate prison all a mow 
aeon:wieldy left to he State of Ronda and not federal aulhonlies. 
without doubt, the boatmen] hal he recened while In state oafody 
undermined the purpose of a jail sentence,' Acosta said. 
Ted earbore spokeswomen for iho Palm Beach County Sharers 
Office: said tie cltoarvrers SKI not have 9 comment PESO 
supervised Epstein while in Sal 
View al single nog. 
teens2Of 2) 
Shoe One ankle. 
COMPAENTS 
enteven not lid 
«ARCM 
Ilich Sawa by TAH/3O1 
lutes 0. t r. tuut wills 
VitsylE LINES 
Fabulous 
Wine, Recipes, 
and More...! 
Find us on FACcbOOk 
Palm SeMPII Daily News 
Uhl 
2...1fICOpC Ik Palla Mach 0441 New. 
!
It\  #111 
MOST RECENT ACNIINS 
1 
Therno AT% 
Mlboryntooron ancr•phon 
Con~mtas 
Alzhabbees 
/clan" 
Conava Can 
En<is.r non", 
o' he Pin-
Seacfio• 
1,1,6 • 
http://www.palmbeachdailynews.com/news/jeffrey-epstein-attorney-roy-black-denies-allega... 5/6/2011 
EFTA00230198

IOZ/9/C "T2011e-s31110P-10M-X01-Xamous-uppda-AawaffiniaufiturssmauApePtpeacitured.Avivairdwi 
!MOOR' bee@ 
a! • 
9V. 
gAid &AAA I sthiliANCIaatizagnied pima 
peal twos Ditsiaalle niptin By AO sisal 
MOM (104 .umealiMalliP00
0 .0•1•4 &DA A. Wiwi man 
ADZ ICA Ceti/1 CALM UJGPS,AdtO 
3IY/A TAY 
*Din 
WV 
iras 
InDar 
SAS 
Argiqffie,44 
sreaw Wye. 
ION 
Rea 
nibs 
witarain 
OMUMI 
awfls
In,A/01 
....now 
SOLIISMIT 
SLIT 
ullal• P1405 
,_, 
Anal nk.,), 
elt•dian00 
ipsawl.wf 
$0019 
baiimo 
&mane 
415% 
11101411VO 
•W 
•9uMeJ 
CLAM 
*WWI 
/MOS 
posop 
itiocutuo3 
•unicktint•Ic 
nee-. 
SosiOn 
WAS 
z jo z abed •••exory Aoulonv •S•fl-xa 
lanai 
suopeitalle sa!upp rem Aux Xatuone uppdg Xatuat 
EFTA00230199

LexisNexis CourtLink - Show Docket 
Page I of LI 
US District Court Civil Docket 
U.S. District - Florida Soutnerr.
(West Palm Beach) 
9:08cv80736 
Doe I. United States of America 
This case was retrieved from the court on Wednesday, March 23, 2011 
oat Filed: 07/07/2008 
Iv:sluts:I To: Judge Kenneth A Hamm 
Selerrad To: 
V.al:4.5m e₹ suit: Civil Rights: Other (440) 
Ca cse: cause specified 
tict-kat: None 
tica-st Orickst: 
U.S. Government Defendant 
Lk-its-Ant; 
Class Code: LIU 
Closed: No 
Statute: no 
Jury Demand: None 
Demand Amount: S$0 
NOS Description: Civil Rights: Other 
Attorneys 
Jane Doe 
Bradley James Edwards 
Petitioner 
Lead Attorney 
Farmer Jaffe WeIssin • Edwards Fstos & Lehrman Pl. 
United States of Amer ca 
Respondent 
Jay C. Howell 
la Howell & Associates PA 
Paul G. Cassell 
Pro Hac Vice 
rn 
N 
• 
Lead Attorney 
United States Attorney's Office 
S00 South Australian Ave 
Suite 400 
https://w3.courtlinklexisnexis.coro/ControlSupport/UserControls/ShowDocket.aspx?Ker... 3/23/2011 
EFTA00230200

LexisNexis Courttink - Show Docket 
Page 2 of 4 
Pft.-)czet1:ng 'text 
03/22/2011 
SYSTEM ENTRY Docket Entry 52 restricted/sealed until further notice. (mg) (Entered: 
03/22/2011) 
51 
Plaintiffs MOTION Jane Doe *1 and lane Doe #2's Motion to Use Correspondence to Prove 
Violations of the Crime Victims' Right Act and to Have Their Unredacted Pleadings Unsealed by 
Jane Doe. le,
) (Entered: 03/21/2011) 
50 
Plaintiffs MOTION lane Dee #1 and Jane Doe #2'S Motion for Order Directing the U.S. 
Attorney's Office Not to Withhold Relevant EvIden e b lane Do . (Attachments: * 1 Exhibit A, 
* 2 Text of Proposed Order PROPOSED ORDER)( 
(Entered: 03/21/2011) 
49 
Plaintiffs MOTION lane Doe *1 and Jane Doe #2's Motion to Have Their Facts Adis
ed 
e of the Government's Fall4re to Contest Any of the Facts by Jane Doe. 
(Entered: 03/21/2011) 
48 
Plaintiffs MOTION for Summary Judgment REDACTED- Jane Doe *1 and Jan Doe #2's Motion 
for Finding of Violations of the Crime Viet' 
' 
Act and Request for Hearing_on_Appropriate
Remedies by Jane Doe. Responses due b' ,_4 
20 
Attachments: JP 1 ExhibitC5-SEALEC/, it 2 
Exhibit 8, # 3 Exhibit C, # 4 Exhibit D, # 5 Exhbk E # 6 tXriltirt r, # TERME G, # 8 Exhibit 
H, # 9 Exhibit I, I 10 Exhibit J, I 11 Exhibit it)I 
(Entered: 03/21/2011) 
03/18/2011 
47 
ORDER granting 46 Motion for L ve to File Excess Pages. Signed by Judge Kenneth A. Marra on 
3/18/2011. (Ir) (Entered: 03/18/2 1) 
03/18/2011 
46 
Unopposed MOTION for Leave to 
Excess Pages of Statement of Facts In Support of their 
Motion for Finding of Violations of th Crime Victims Right Act by Jane Doe. (Attachments: # 1 
Text of Proposed Order)(Edwards, Br 
ey) Modified on 3/18/2011 (Is). (Entered: 03/18/2011) 
12/17/2010 
45 
STATUS REPORT by United States of America (1.
1 (Entered: 12/17/2010) 
10/28/2010 
44 
ORDER REOPENING CASE. Signed by Judge Kenneth A. Man-a on 10/28/2010. (Ir) (Entered: 
10/28/2010) 
10/28/2010 
43 
Clerks Notice to Flier re 41 Status Report. Two or More Document Events Filed as One; ERROR - 
Only one event was selected by the Filer but more than one event was applicable to the 
document Med. The docket entry was corrected by the Clerk. It is not necessary to refile this 
document but in the future, the Filer must select all applicable events. (Is) (Entered: 
10/28/2010) 
10/27/2010 
RESPONSE TO ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE by Jane Doe. (ls)(See Image at DE * 41 ) (Entered: 
10/28/2010) 
Order to Show Cause on 10/28"Hil l,Pred: 
10/27/2010) 
10/27/2010 
STATUS REPORT by lane Doe 
Modified to add missing event 42 Response to 
10/12/2010 
ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE for lack of prosecution. Show Cause Response due by 10/27/2010. 
Signed by Judge Kenneth A. Marra on 10/8/2010. (ir) (Entered: 10/17/2010) 
09/13/2010
NOTIC 
38 Administrative Order In Response to Administrative Order Closing 
Case 
(Entered: 09/13/2010) 
09/08/2010 
Administrative Order Closing Case. Signed by Judge Kenneth A. Marra on 9/8/2010. (tb) 
(Entered: 09/09/2010) 
West Palm Beach , FL 33401 
USA 
Lead Attorney 
/03/21/2011 
/03/21/2011 
/03/n/2011 
%%3/21/2011 
49 
50 .) 
e 
https://w3.courtlink.lexisnexis.com/CoatrolSupport/UserConttols/ShowDocket.aspx?Key... 3/23/2011 
EFTA00230201

• --- --------------- 
• 
LexisNexis CourtLink - Show Docket 
Page 3 of 4 
04/09/2009 
37 
NOTICE by Jane Doe of Change of Firm Affiliation a) 
(Entered: 04/09/2009) 
02/12/2009 
36 
ORDER denying 28 MoUon to Unseal Document. Signed by Judge Kenneth A. Marra on 
2/12/2009. Or) (Entered: 02/12/2009) 
12/22/2008 
AFFIDAVIT signed by : A. Marie 1fillafana. re 14 Affioavit, 13 Response/Reply (Other) 
Supplemental Declaration by United States of America. (Attachments: a 1 Certification 
Certificate of Service) i 
(Entered: 12/22/2008) 
12/09/2008 
34 
Clerks Notice of Docket Correction re 33 Sealed Document. Error(s): Sealed Document Filed in 
Wrong Case; Correction - Original document restricted and refired in correct case. (rb) (Entered: 
12/09/2008) 
12/05/2008 
SYSTEM ENTRY - Docket Entry 32 restricted/sealed until further notice. (el) (Entered: 
11/03/2010) 
12/05/2008 
33 
Sealed Document. (rb) (Entered: 12/05/2008) 
10/17/2008 
-- 
Clerks Notice of Docket Correction and Instruction to Flier re 30 Response/Reply (Other), 
Response/Reply (Other) filed by Jane Doe. Error - Wrong Event Selected; Correction - 
Redocketed by Clerk as Reply to Response to Motion. Instruction to Filer - In the future, please 
select the proper event. It is not necessary to refile this document. (Is) (Entered: 10/17/2008) 
10/16/2008 
31 _-REPLY to Response to Motion re 28 MOTION to Unseal Document Non-Prosecution Agreement 
flied by Jane Doe. (See Image at DE *30] (Is) (Entered: 10/17/2008) 
10/16/2008 
30 
RESPONSE/REPLY to 29 Response in Opposition to Motion to Unseal Non-Prosecution Agreement 
flied by Jane Doe. Attachments: 9 1 Exhibit October 9, 2008 letter from Brad Edwards, Esquire 
to AUSA 
>Y 2 Exhibit October 15, 2008 Letter from Brad Edwards, Esquire to AUSA 
(Entered: 10/16/2008) 
10/08/2008 
29 
RESPONSE In Opposition re 28 MOTION to Unseal Document Non-Prosecution Agreement filed 
by United States of America. 
ntered: 10/08/2008) 
09/25/2008 
28 
MOTION to Unseal Document Non-Prosecution Agreeme 
sponseS due by 
10/14/2008 (Attachments: * I Text of Proposed order) 
(Entered: 
09/25/2008) 
08/22/2008 
27 
TRANSCRIPT of Hearing held on 8/14/2008 before Judge Kenneth A. Marra. Court Reporter: 
Stephen Franklin - phone number 561-514-3768 25 pages. (ad) (Entered: 08/25/2008) 
08/21/2008 
26 
ORDER TO COMPEL PRODUCTION AND PROTECTIVE ORDER. Signed by Judge Kenneth A. Marra 
on 8/21/08. (Ir) (Entered: 08/21/2008) 
08/20/2008 
24 
NOTICE of Instruction to Flier: re 22 Notice (Other) filed by United States of America Error: 
Wrong Event Selected; Instruction to filer - In the future please select the proper event. (Is) 
(Entered: 08/20/2008) 
08/14/2008 
25 
Minute Entry for proceedings held before Judge Kenneth A. M 
• 
ference held on 
8/14/2008. Court Reporter: Stephen Franklin- phone number 
ir) (Entered: 
08/21/2008) 
08/13/2008 
23 
ORDER Setting Status Conference: Status Conference set for 8/14/2008 03:30 PM in West Palm 
before Judge Kenneth A. Marra. Parties may contact the courtroom deputy at 
make arrangements to appear telephonically. Signed by Judge Kenneth A. 
Marra on 8/13/08. (Jr) (Entered: 08/13/2008) 
08/13/2008 
22 
NOTICE by United States of America re 19 Response/Reply (Other), Response/Reply (Other) 
Government's Res 
e to Petitioners' Request for Non-Prosecution Agreement and Report of 
Interview 
Entered: 08/13/2008) 
08/13/2008 
21 
ENDORSED ORDER granting Jay C. Howell 20 Motion for Limited Appearance, Consent to 
Designation and Request to Electronically Receive Notices of Electronic Filings. Signed by Judge 
Kenneth A. Marra on 8/12/08. (Ir) (Entered: 08/13/2008) 
08/08/2008 
20 
MOTION for United Appearance, Consent to DftignatIon and Request to Electronically Receive 
Notices of Electronic Fling for Jay C. Howell, Filing Fee $75, Receipt *724591. (cw) (Entered: 
08/12/2008) 
08/01/2008 
RESPONSE/REPLY to Goverment's Notice to Court Regarding Absence of Need for Evidentiary 
Hearing and Motion for Production of Non-Prosecution Agreement and of Report of Interview 
filed by Jane Doe. (Attachments: 0 1 Exhibit Proposed Stipulation, * 2 Exhibit July 17, 2008 
Letter, * 3 Exhibit July 3, 2008 Letter) 
(Entered: 08/01/2008) 
07/30/2008 
18 
ENDORSED ORDER granting Paul G. Cassell 16 Motion for Limited Appearance, Consent to 
Designation and Request to Electronically Receive Notices of Electronic Filings. Signed by Judge 
Kenneth A. Marra on 7/29/08. (ir) (Entered: 07/30/2008) 
hups://w3.courtlink.lexisnexis.com/ControlSupport/UserControls/ShowDocketaspx?Kcy=... 3/23/2011 
EFTA00230202

LexisNexis CourtLink - Show Docket 
Page 4 of 4 
07/29/2008 
17 
07/28/2008 
16 
07/17/2008 
07/11/2008 
11 
07/11/2008 
10 
07/11/2008 
07/10/2008 
07/09/2008 
07/09/2008 
07/09/2008 
12 
07/09/2008 
8 
07/09/2008 
7 
07/09/2008 
6 
07/09/2008 
07/07/2008 
3 
0 
NOTICE 
• 
tes of America To Court Regarding Absence of Need for Evidentiary 
Hearin 
(Entered: 07/29/2008) 
MOTION for Limited Appearance, Consent to Designation and Request to Electronically Receive 
Notices of Electronic Filing for Paul G. Cassell, Filing Fee $75, Receipt #724532. (cw) (Entered: 
07/28/2008) 
TRANSCRIPT of Hearing held on 7 11 2008 before Judge Kenneth A. Marra. Court RepOrter: 
Victoria Mello- phone numb 
2 pages. (abd) (Entered: 07/18/2008) 
ORDER Denying Motion to Seal re 7 Sealed Document, 6 Sealed Document, 8 Sealed Document. 
Signed by Judge Kenneth A. Marra on 7/11/2008. (Is) (Additional attachments) added on 
7/15/2008: t 1 docket sheet) (be). (Entered: 07/14/2008) 
Minute Entry for proceedings held before Judge Kenneth A. Marra: Miscellaneous Hearing held 
on 7/11/2008. Court will issue order to unseal pleadings. Court Reporter: Official Reporting 
Service- phone number
) (Entered: 07/11/2008) 
REPLY to Response (under seal) re 1 CompalnVEmergency Petition, and Objection to 
Government's Motion for Sealing of Pleadings filed by Jane Doe. (Is) (Entered: 07/11/2008) 
5 
ORDER SETTING HEARING: Petitioner's Emergency Petition for Enforcement of Crime Victim's 
Rights Act set for 7/11/2008 10:15 AM in West Palm Beach Division before Judge Kenneth A. 
Marra. Sired by Judge Kenneth A. Marra on 7/10/08. Ir) (Entered: 07/10/2008) 
14 
UNSEALED DECLARATION signed by 
Petition by United States of America. 
07/15/2008) 
13 
UNSEALED RESPONSE to 1 Emergency Petition for Enforcement of Crime Victim Rights Act filed 
by United States of America. (previously Med as 7 sealed document) (be) (Entered: 
07/15/2008) 
UNSEALED MOTION to Seal Response to Victim's Emergency Petition by United States of 
America. (previously filed as 6 sealed document) (bs) (Entered: 07/15/2008) 
• 
Sealed Document. (rb) UNSEALED See DE 14 . Modified on 7/15/2008 (bs). (Entered: 
07/10/2008) 
Sealed Document. (rb) UNSEALED see DE 13 . Modified on 7/15/2008 (bs). (Entered: 
07/10/2008) 
Sealed Document. (rb) UNSEALED see DE 12 . Modified on 7/15/2008 (bs). (Entered: 
07/10/2008) 
4 
NOTICE of Attorney Appearance by 
on behalf of United States of America 
Entered: 07/09/2008) 
ORDER requiting U.S. Attorney to respond to 1 Complaint filed by Jane Doe by 5:00 p.m. on 
7/9/08. Signed by Judge Kenneth A. Marra on 7/7/08. (Ir) (Entered: 07/07/2008) 
07/07/2008 
2 
CERTIFICATE OF EMERGENCY by Jane Doe re 1 Complaint (rb) (Entered: 07/07/2008) 
07/07/2008 
1 
EMERGENCY PETITION for Victim's Enforcement of Crime Victim's Rights Act 18 USC 3771 
against United States of America Filing fee $ 350. Receipt*: 724403, riled by Jane Doe.(rb) 
(Entered: 07/07/2008) 
13 Response to Victim's Emergency 
previous 
I 
as 
seated document) (bs) (Entered: 
Copyright (0 2011 LexisNexis Couittink, Inc. All rights reserved. 
*os THIS DATA IS FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY 'In 
https://w3.courtlinklexisnexis.com/ControlSupport/UserControls/ShowDocket.aspx?Key=... 3/23/2011 
EFTA00230203

LexisNexis CoutLink— Docket Number Search Result 
/7 a.,, 15 c 
Page 1 of 4 
texisNexis• Couraink• 
Single Search - with Tents and Cannaestoes 
1 
'Enter keywords - Search multiple dockets 
& documents 
Mill 
atom SW
i Hy CoartUat ?tl Searchi ll 
Dockets liDecineenti
ca 
Mort ITtrategic 
noses 
ary AcHrant :\ 
el 
Suite 
> pggligamaggi > Did,, WOW States al Starks 
!taloa Ws 
F.:thre 006 .ese no I PAIIIINtrillidlat 
I lall.somi SWICALIWSHISOC43Af 
Welame, JACQUELINE R0tGATSCN 
er.:7::=1 1=1=1 
Docket Toole 
Got Undated Decteil 
tau* ,  tuutrewilit-  .. i 
-- agut kr Similar to 
. 
This ecetst en ..awed muds* Can alert pA. 
',tan • roe tat , P. 
1,e A flat St, 
VOW Whet theme ay fAtIctiatlasetcasel 
ROT MIAOW on 
when Hog gate letivily 
Hied on the 
Ate Ca= that Hatch 
UAJW Ohs Oman.' 
4015/2011 
S. the arse 
charactenclics of Cris 
cissractenstics of this 0614 
itElenlYttkiletat: 
. 
tate 
Acitlitiond reremeres for HOW toe this may be rourci in DAT I Agate/Axis drama Amu:0mm tern 
DOG
Onalatt=1 
US District Court Civil Docket 
U.S. District 
- Florida Southern 
(West Palm Beach) 
0:013cv80736 
Doe 
United States of America 
/Ms awe win re lend from the court ea Friday, .pis LS, 3011 Widatotigg 
Dere /Nee 07/07/20011 
class code. LIO 
Assumed re. Judge Nemeth A Harm 
Closed: NO 
Reigered TO 
Pettit.: 
Mature of Sett Cleft Rights: Mew (440) 
Any Demand, Merle 
Chia,: cos spacified 
Oe.nand Arnoviel asp 
Lead Oeckel: None 
NOS Destilletteee Civil Rights: Mbar 
Other Docket: 
Jurisdiction: U.S. Governmem Defendant 
lire Der 
Ration 
ui, teo States effluence 
eintetbdellt 
Litigants 
Attorneys 
Bradier.lansalcaM 
L ad Attorney 
Pre Mac Vice 
Attatney to be Peeked 
taJd Atterety 
Vetted S.Ates Attorney'S terc. 
SOD So-th Auftglen Ave 
Suite 404 
Mat poem Death 
)5401
USA 
• 
https://w3.courdink.lexisnexis.com/Searcb/CaseNumberSearch_Result.aspx?SearchPackag... 4/18/2011 
EFTA00230204

-----
1 - 
LexisNexis 
Col.ttLink 
- Docket Numbcr Search Result 
Page 2 of 4 
1•10 Atan« 
Odecl States >arne 011Ice 
95 NI 4 Street 
Mal , PL 33122 
VSA 
Roy Dleck 
5.:RIGAto 
larvene 
"5;0 SEI 
itmk, S'eJlInCx. KlYlet.il Ofl & !lu,nY P.A 
...utte 
Pniek 
tad( •••-nnt. Sperre Jk 
ley135Ykaa 
~Of 
11G.J.LP 
leln.Q.11091.7er9 
Se  G aen, 
Pr 
20 ra Psaza 
Sa 1000 
ame MA 02116 
VSA 
notes/lent* 
hems 1 to 69 of 69 
Ayellebetny Pro. 
Gale 
Pott:ela takt 
I frterl
EMERGENCY PETITION fat YlaTme Inforterat of Crime Wca. Aas Ad 18 Ia 3771 aselest 
.07707/2008 oUred
/07/250c4
tae 
) of AsnerN5 Anne fm g 350. Reommt: 724503, 8ed by 74na 009.00) (entoms: 
7
2 
07/07/20D8 CERTKOSTE OF EtleRGINCY by Ja Dot re i Cape -1 (rt) (Enbsnacl: 07/07/2038) 
ORDER reoula U.S. Scomey lo menn K* Cornalrt nie0 ty Jam Doe 05 5:00 pa. on 7/9/05. 
3 
97197/2996 SignEl by Aas lannign A Hem a 7/7/C4. (r) (Entwed: 07/07/2008) 
cpunt 
i  
on09/200, N011a Of Att0If 
anna 
by 
Oehee of United Sta of Arma 
(Eatered: 07/09/2008) 
Runnet 
6 ,D7A)9/20015 Seale0 Oocan•-. (ib) UN5EALED set DE 12 . legled en 7/15/2008 (e5). (Enteretl: 07/10/2008) 
Rune 
7 
337/09/3000 Sars Dane 
(Ib) urdsvao sa DE 13 . mocured on 7/15/2008 (05). (fred: 07/10/2006) 
Ruiner 
8 :07/09/2006 Sela Dame Mb) UtaKE0 
Of 14 . ~ned on 7/15/2Cel: (b5). (Entra 07/10/2005) 
UMSeAlED MOTION to Seal Reponse to Wales Etneracy Peon by united Ste of Anterce. 
23;une 
12 07/00/2006 (peyosynsly Med a5 6 Sealet1 auet) 
OM) (Ente: 07/15/2999) 
umsta.ro RESPONSE to 1 LireGerey Pols» ro; .5.1ftertent of Ceehl Viden Renta Ad Ila tty 
K 20.512 
13 :D7/09/ 2008 Vie am of Paria (a40U9y Ila as 7 %eigd Gammelt) (i6) (97IGGRIG 07715/ 2008) 
UNSIALED DECLARATION ase by : 
13 apa* 
to em i enssoncy 
o Ø.14 
!07/09/20:36 
Pe5/203S)
on by Une SteNS of Amtal. tpnmokwy 'som* sal ClOtselere) (DS) (Entelte: 
OROlR 
07/1 
Sell1NG MURING: allone75 intergeney aten 
Inforcement of Gnr* Wca Ronts 
ctvies 
5 
'07/10/20D8: halet ref 7/11/700810:15 AM In Wen Pta Ne Oman bare Jusaa Kannovi A. Mara. Synes 
by Ale nenne A. rent ca n10/96. (Ir) (gned: 07/1072: 05) 
Ofte 
9 
99111,2999;mobou
RgleXCIrjo:45
5: ".
.enp *trungi:I
nder lEal)
nas nteiblibiCarra)"
be 077.(:)ricY
(Entered:
Pe"°
07%."1/20
d t
jectian
) 
te ~menn
• aule eta fa' proopeongs ald Ner. X49. Kinnet% A. ma4a: Maareous heng Initi eit 
Runner 
10 07/11/7074 7/11/2008 Roa mn aue ore to uneeal pIeaflogs. Court Reporter: Oftlnal Repain3 Sere 
Phooe ninbar 
(tnte/00 07/11/2008) • 
Dale 
;11 07/11/2e ° 9-199 CeIT 59 Milt0710 5915 Tel 
7 %Men faure 
6 Sea Dement: il Sela Ocanent 
'Simlen by ludo* Anne A. ara or 7/11/2005. (b) (Aoafal 5fteonfneas) ode on 7/15/2035: 
https://w3.courtlink.lexisnexis.com/Search/CaseNumberSearch_Result.aspx?SearchPackag... 4/18/2011 
EFTA00230205

• 
-i 
trfccAr<A,-- — 
''1 
LexisNexis CotztLink - Rocket Number Scarch Result 
Page 3 of 4 
n ceb. 
15 
o 
16 
• 
n opne 
17 
Rormø 
ta= 
Renner 
• 1 dosis snes) (u). (Vitna ONN/1~ 
07/17/2000 TRANSCIUO or ~rin; hald on 7/11/2005 beror* /tilsi Kenneth A. Moro Court INNter: INtotie 
9hTM na!~ 
2 P4099 (ad) (Nesa. 07/1412008) 
MOTION be Ltntral 
tobent 
Amtererce, 
ø Destration mer%west to Electronleolly Remba Notbos 
07/34/2001 
rot hul G Con« 
tettnat Wirb 
PI«) Ne VG LON 47245)2. (cw) (entret 07/24/2;706) 
• 07133/2003 NONCE. Dy United States et Roere To «urt RepardIN ANNO 0PN~ br E)404WW4 Marine 
(arrep: 07/29/2004) 
IMIDORSED ORPER Dransme Mtsi G. CaSSel 1E MW 
For ~Kl apparat" Gement Dis:etan 
IS 07/31)/»ffli and Knust to aocusicaly Nabo «Mel Of ~rene Fikst Slenge by ;utbe ~nem A. 14erro 
 
 
712WOS (Ir) (Entered Ofilty20111) 
_ 
:RESPONSEMEPLY to G:N.~1CH Nodoe to Court Re«Ping ~te 
of NN tor Evipmfaty nying 
, 
ion. Hoho ror Weducten uf SpoProexeCon Awwyment end of Report Cf Ints• 
Mod by Jane Co.. 
19 
i • 
lAttamnknts: p 1 CAN« Propoeed Stipuleban, a 2 !nyt N( I?, 2025 tetter, ! 3 LOGN Ny 3, 
20« settsy(Emparck. bad ley) (fniste. 04/01/2006) 
MOTION fot Limte; Afflararal, ~ni 
te ONIGNUe• and Rinwest to Ekaronpally ~ve Noti« 
22 °2424/2444 of Mectronc 11:1« ror My C. Howell, Fi1n0 Fet 575, «amt .224591. (try) (Enter« 05/12/2035) 
eNDORSIN ORDER granen; Ny C. HOwl111 20 Motion for UmIted Apwteranee, Ombot to ON9440011 
21 05/13/200t and Reeuelt to Ellectrontelly Recelo NOENS Of DectrOnS rin« Siguarl bylt/Ege Kinne« A. Narra 
On 8/12/09 Ur) grend: 06/9/3005) 
:NOME 
Unitel5(Mhat of anerles ni 19 Raspdrise/RoMy (ONN). R. COnte/AcC•1 (07N/er) 
22 :06/13/202INGIntenmer 
Rabbi:inn' Stotwest ror Non-Prociebbon kytement and Heppi of 
'Mumles ( 
entret 04/13/2:08) 
:OROER SEM® Status Conference: Sml« Conference/ Sot br 8/14/20013 0130 P14 in west Ram 
04040,20„:9«ch Oysion «fore ludoe «NN A. Mn. Pa« ny Ne« the countoorn «pult, et 561 -514 
3765 to make erfeneements to oppar MIONIONatly. ~ed 
ludge Kenneth /1 Mana on 8/13/08. 
(4)(Entered: 06/13/2006) 
25 06/14/20088/1W2008. Can Reporter Stoptur Fmnidn- phone n 
IN (Enter« 
Nnute &Dy Mr procotongt SN bekre Jed94 Hesent& 
" 
NN" 
06/21/2001) 
RPDTICE or Instnanin to Rer: re 22 Ntlos lOther) NA Pl Vo&WIStabes cf America N« 42Corb 
24 00120/2036 
SeaxttKI: ImtructOn to mer n IN klin «Nise sel« tro proper tron. (e) (Bnbitod; 
05/20/2005) 
un.. ORDER TO compa. PASYDVC110.1 AND PROTECNY! GMÆR. 51pned by 3udge Kenneen A. Mant on 
3 Måne 
20 '001211••o• insfos (y) (!nr«: 0421/2008) 
O , Daa 
oef22/2008 TAANSCRIPT of Hann? 
B beise lalge Kenneth A. Muse. Court legerte,: Stephen 
%ND • Noko Pumpet 
Søg« 1•04) (LINN DE/13/70: 0) 
Cl .frtist 
2s 09/25/200e MOTION lo Unges bocsment lien•Prowatt 
Oto. Respons« Ne by 10/14/200G 
~Net: 
I i Text of Proosed Ord 
(Inter« 09/25/20211) 
RES:NISSE:n croottoon re 26 monar to uosom DocutrOlt IN-Prosecuton 45renment Ned by 
mPs 
29 10/C41/2G°13 IMMO SUEN Of *merka. a[Entered: 
toms/2001) 
RUPONSt/RDNY to 29 RpowPie In Oppetaen to MOlfon tO UNNI 140wProsecution Apreement sloa 
30 10/16/200e 
(AGachmeNS: a : NN« «Ner G 2008 letter bonl Dr« COMNS, 
uke to AUSA 
(Frier«: 10/16/2008) 
rMOR «NN 15. K« lotto Aperi Stal lessa, Csqult• to Alba 
(SKY to Respons.. to Motion re 26 MOTION te ~Ha Desimert Noran0590(tIOR ManNiment Med by 
aber« 
31 10/16/200e /ane DM. (54e Image åt OL 110) DG 
10/17/2036) 
:Oerles Noba of DiNCCCONSPDIon at InSONIN o Pile re X Reeponse/ReIbt («her), 
m.fl« 
40a
204„:Reiconbe/neply (Øer) Med by Jam Co.. Error Ylmne IN•fet NKS 
CoIrrOson • Relmitated bY 
CM« a Repty LO Rettelse to /Mon. Inf Smilen to Feer - In tre rulse. Messe satt ds prOper
Ove« It k n« MOMSEN lo reke the dusement. (k) (BONN' 10/17/2008) 
33 12/05/20011 SNOE ~mens (rb) (lEnterett: 12/05/2606) 
— 
12/05/2000 SYSTEM ENTRY Oodst Intly 32 nwrisetlbeaMO unte furthry AMI« (cg) (Cnteng: i 1/113/21710) 
CIO« NN« of «eltet Gene:ska re 33 Soled Dont 
EITOCS), SIMIN Decurrent Nit n NYO% 
34 27/09/2008 Gr.; Cortectica - «OHM chteument ~kW 
end ~cl in «tea ase. (M) (ENN: 
17/09/200.1 
,AWIDAVIT sign« Dy : .1~ 
te 14 ANM«. 13 Rescrame/Re« ansi SuPolennentel 
35 12/22(2,38, 
ti •• 
• 
b Ce ArmetA. (Abonnent!: • 1 Catnopt»o unntar or ~to) 
temd. 12/12/2005) 
'ORDER ~Ing «Mot« to ~ai Document. Skre by Nalst Kenneth A. Mure an 2/1211009 (Ir) 
34 02117/2" (bitne: 02/12/2009) 
37 04/09/2009 NOWCE by /ane Doe Of Oren« Of Fon MONN a~r 
(Entertd: 0409/2009) 
ACm•1St~ breer Oce4n) Case. Stied by 2iidge Kinreth A Harm 
9/W2010. (tb) (Entet:
09/123/2010 0443413010) 
NOTIS! by Sone Dos 
40eniehtrative Order In Respxsa to AdmIrestratse Ords Oceirci Case 
39 22/13/2410 (Edwards, 51110N) (Enter« 09/13/2010) 
ORDER TO SHOW CM.« br lick ef peceOppion. Rico amle Rapar« due by 10/27/2010. Slutta 
22±121" 14 by Mg. Kn 
A. mrel on 10/8)2010. (c) (Enbutd: 10/12/2010) 
„ 
.10227/201b STATUS REPORT try rom Co. (loora, ørner) mone tO e« milkw0 ON 42 Reetter« Io Orde 
Sfrow Sause on 10/ 28/ 2010 DO. (EOnd: 10/27/2010) 
_ 
GESPCNSE TO ordnes 'ro SHOW CAUSE by Seneo. 
D
. (6)4500 Nepe at DE Ir 41 1 (Entaned: 
42 12/22/2010 10/29/2010) 
* ne
 NON to Ner re 41 SMDS RebOrt. Ta, 
Nore Docurrent Co« Ned as One; ERROR Only 
43 mani " 
*nemnt ne autokam try Mo Mer he more Man oner mint sos trolde ta Me «Hum« Med. 
!MØNA' ny los mumlet; by the Clertt It Is not nimossery 10 reile tnt. decurnent DS in the 
5 
bast the Nar mot snoet al rappliceble Bente. (10 (ENN: 10/20/2010) 
.44 ile/2022m ORDER REOPENING CASE. SON. by Apte Rennen A. Narre P 15242010. (Ir) rentens: 
10/24#201cs 
-- 
• 
45 12/17/2010 STATUS REPORT try Unt« SUEN or ~Not 
(IMeret 12/17/20110 
; 
,Uninobee MOTS« fm imme a) File EANSI Nat Of Statemem of Foss In Snert or tre NORM Mr 
.411 t03/15/2011:flnern; of 
i 
4 Cm« «Oms' Nøt Adby »ne DOe. ~mot: 
I 1 Temd Neppe« 
ioyder 
Hocreto 011 3/16(2011 (Is). (eter«: 03/18/2011) 
47 03/12/2011•01UMR groen; 46 Hot« Co. «øve M Pile bien Miget. SIOMII ly hese Kennel A. Mana On 
3/EW2011. (En !Snerpa: 03/1(820/ 
08 02,21,,„.,„ 1 
 Pinneles 40110N br Sannwry lueement REOACITD- kne D« *1 amt lan Doe /Ds ten for 
. 
Pffidng ot Yolatuns urvne Crime vorstr sirs Act orid ~art ra «adm) On fewroprIera 
rklpflIOU by Jono tron Itoporees du by 47/2011 (Attectorw«: • I Critro• A.SEA•40. • 2 latt 
https://w3.courtlink.lexisnexis.com/Search/CaseNumberSearch_Result.aspx?SearcliPackag... 4/18/2011 
EFTA00230206

" 7-7, r • 
- 
FTERR7i557 
LexisNexis CourtLink - Docket Number Search Result 
Page 4 of 4 
• 
o 031100 
49 
K Cale 
SO 
Ws 
St 
Reset 
AJnner 
53 
ague 
54 
O filar 
55 
OaMp 
56 
o EtEn.e 
57 
' O Crane 
• 55 
n catais
99 
.04/77/7711 
Is. a 3 CMS C, 1 4 DAS D 15 tows F 
6 test F, • 7 Exhen 0, • I timed H. 19 Erehmet 
,1, 5 10 EROS 3. I 11 EMISI K) 
Ached MOTION Oar Hosing on ameconate 
reenedia On 3/23/2011 Oh). (Ente 
11 
03/71/2011: the Government's FatetO EMUS Any or Vie FWD by lane Om. 
(Enterer 
Platt s MOTION /one Coo el and Jane Doe Ors Motto to Ms 
Sempuse of 
03/21/2019 
'Plertiffs NOTION Jane Co. in and Jane Doe En Motion for Order Directing the US. Atiorneys 
03/21/2011 Offs Not te YantrOld Relavare EH 
(Attachments: a 1 EmeltA a 2 Tut of 
,Promeod order PROPOSED ORDER)( 
(Enters: 03/21/2011) 
beintaffs MOTION Pane Co. e1 and Jena Doo X 23 Motion to Use Correspondence to Prom Viacom 
03/21./2011 
reo 
s' Night Act and to Have Their Unredected Peaditym Unsealed by Um Dew 
(EnterOd: 03/21/2011) 
in/22am 1 SYSTEM ENTRY • Dectiet enter 52 natelcbcPsealed Lintel native nolia. (me) (Entered: 03/2712011) 
Dens Notice to flier re 48 Plaintiffs 140110N for Drawn lommere REOACTED- Uwe Doe *1 anti 
Mn Doe ers Macon fee Finelem of whelks of the Crewe Vetirror Reis AC end Request for Irwin; 
co Aoprowlate Re nede 110110N For Hewing. M000n wet Maple Reliefs Red as One Relief; ERROR 
03/23/2011 - The Hier Mooted onN one newt east wed FOS to soca the adchtimai arreSporMing evenb for 
an rCYY emeveted ei the elan. The anal any wart cm Netted by the Mot It is net gemology 
:to mete thes domment act Nero Mims mast corroly wan me nstrucelonS in the Ori/ECN Attorney 
Users Manal. (n) (Emmo!: 03/23/2011) 
.NOTICE by Roy Sisk re 50 Neenah MOTION Jane 00e 51 and Jane Doe 525 beton Me Order 
;Droning the US Attorney's Offeze Peat to Withhor4 Relevant Evidence. 51 *MUM* MOTION Um Oar 
0300/2011 DI end Jim Doi • 29 MID to tRro Celrepondence to Prove Vhslatess of the Urea Wane' leoht 
Act and to hive Their ureolatted Mecum Unseoed NOTICES OISJECTICes (819*, Roy) (Enlaced: 
'03/28/7011) 
MOTION to 4PPeer Pro ESC VOI, Consent b 08161InitIon, and Ragusa to Eterlremeilly Readsre 
04/04/2011 Notices of nee* 
Mem for Martin barbers). POMO Fee $ 75733. Receipt • 16710. (104 (Entered: 
04/05/2011) 
MOTION to Intoning of Roy Mick Harlin Weintsit aro )ay LefkOwA7 by kw Block. (Peretek 
leameine) (Entered: 04/07/3011) 
0407/201/ States Of Ale ate. (At171d1MeisS: • I ExhIbt A,• 2 MA of Roomed Ord 
(Entered: 
Defendant's MOTION for leave
 FM Merneranceten of La* M MOSS of 
United 
04207/2011) 
. 
RESPONSE i0 OCCOSIGGI re 49 Plairars MOTION Jane Doe El and Pine DM *79 Hoban to Have 
0407/7011 intir FOC1S ACM 
e CelYernmentt 1911re 10 Genteel Any et MO nets n
 United 
_ 
es 
star 
or *mono ( 
Erbred: 04/07/2011) 
RESPONSE In OF7OSItIon re SO Pei ruin MOTION Mae Own and lane Doe *2's Motion for Order 
.04/07/2011 Directing :se U.S. Attorney's Of
 Not to etidtheal Roe/tint NEMO, ONO by Vested Suite of 
• 
Arsica. a 
(Enters: 04007/2011) 
Kin NeSe in Osmotic* re SI ENIMEns MOTION teen Da II end Jar Doe • rs Mohan to Use 
O 
QNLnO 
.60 ism/canon cerrescomence to Prove Violatte6 Of the Cabe Stirrer Right/1cl tied to Hive Thar UrridiCteti 
FleadleNS Unsealed filed by United States of Arnett*. a 
(Entered' 04/07/20111 
• 
ENDORSIO ORDER owing 57 *Mon for Leon to Ole WarncrindUin of Um in Ent el Twenty 
Ronnie 
bi r 
20a ups.
 Mike: Fier must separatety re-Nle Me arrended Web*, Pungent DS IM
Rule 15.4 
otherwise ordered by tne Mews Sired by Judge Kenreeth A. Nene on 4/411. Pt) anwed. 
04042011) 
RESPONSE in Omosition re 41 Plaintas MOTION br Surereney Judgment REDACTED/ ham Doe el 
, r,„ as Jan Doe En Moho, for fading of VIC400,13 eft the Orme Halms' Ragas 
Ades
 Reapest for 
1 SLUM 
62 
—" Hewing or tworwriate gemeSto MOTION Ow Haring Ned by United Seams of America-
(Mewed 04/042011) 
. 
. 
_ 
Runner 
— 
04/08/2011 SYSTEM EMILY - Docket Entry 63 naPetteWsealed until fUrther notice OD (Entered: 0400/2011) 
Runner 
0406/3041 SYSTEM WRY - Docks Entry 61 reptricted/seeled until Anther notn (0.0 (Entered: 1:04001/2011) 
MOTION err Extension online to Fib ReSponse/Recly es to 46 Pleenaffs MOTION far Summary 
Judgment REDACTED- Mae Os I I and 1M 000 52's Moon kr Comm of Volations of the Cdr.* 
• %Rams' Keats Art and Request ler Neareng en Asropesete Remedies MOTION !Di Hearing lane Doe 
J trace 
65 04413/201I *1 and Ms Doe ra unopposed 
for 
Tie 
Mmon 
Two Weak Erasion of hoe and For PerrnEssOn to 
an 
OmeleingUe Ropy 
sea to slit Motor.by lane Doe EPALIChFrOntl I 1 hot of 
- 
-•-• 
- 
- 
JP:Goosed Order 
(Entered:  04/13/201s1 
I ORDER Wanting 65 mots for Extenvon of limo lc into Respoese/Reily re 46 Plaintiffs MOTION for 
Suermaly Judgment atoaCrefr lee Oes inane Jan Doe E2's Mats for findIngcntelemens of the 
66 04/141201110 n 
virtaThe 54m5 lc 400 Request for Psalm; On Aparopente rtenesan MOTION for Morino. 
.194/14.147/2044211bY 512/2011. Mined by hedge wen d nein ae anrinol 1. pri (friend: 
!MOTION for Extension of Time to Filo Respoeseassly as to 56 MOTION to intervene of Rey Medi. 
o' 
67 04/1.4/7011 
In welted. end lay Lebowitz lane Doe El and laicDoe in Unomosed Hots Not Emorolm of 
221Efi 
nem to Coordinate Fay 
Intl to Meted tD Intents by /tine Co.. (ktiOnnerkti: 
Text of Proposed 0•0140) 
ffiDeold: 04/1420I1) 
maim le Appear Pro Mec Mos Consent to DOM/MUM and Request ED EleclsOfecally RceJve 
CialEile 
-ea '04/14/2011 
04 
Nakao onsectroric Ping rfa Jay Leleovela. Filing Fee* 75,00 ReCelpt 
17328. 0wa) (Enteret 
/16/1011) 
Items Ito 69 or 69 
C1==ltal 11=111=15 
Need • better solution for recetvino end sending service in you/ cases/ Cat more control over mentoget9 service ia all 
of yew cases end reduce a•yeCiallud eyoreedel w.111 LosisNrs..s foe R Serve I • Service. Getting stinted be easy. Calf 
1 900.669.1910 a.' dick borst 
LexisNexis 
vc.•Oo(klit'saartil 
About Lasaxl, I TOCr* & Craws I Ms .0 1 ntenev 
CottOneer Saari • 1-H/-311.1906 
copyelght O 2011 lexiMmtial. All dos mewed. 
https://w3.courdinkiexisnexis.com/S earch/CaseNumberSearch_Result.aspx?SearchPackag... 4/18/2011 
EFTA00230207